Afloat magazine readers voted overwhelmingly for the Asgard to be lifted in an online poll. Disappointingly, three months on, she remains at the bottom of the sea. Now in February 2009, Afloat have opened an online petition to provide a meaningful voice for everyone who wants to save the ship and Irish sail training before it's too late....

Dear Minister O'Dea, "Over 10,000 have learned the ropes on her deck, many of them from across the religious divide on our island. She flew the tricolour in hundreds of ports around the world, providing positive and cost effective international exposure for this nation. And she served as a tangible link to our recent and turbulent past. On an island nation that so often turns its back on the sea, Asgard II – built by Irish hands, inspired by Irish history, recognised around the globe – came to symbolise all that was possible for our maritime industry. Recognising the unique role played by this brigantine, we, the undersigned, call on the Irish government to move immediately to salvage her and begin work on her restoration. We also call on the Irish government to commit to the future of the sail training programme, in the event that Asgard II cannot now be salvaged, by setting out a timetable for the commissioning of a replacement vessel".

If you agree we need your name for the petition. Click here then type your name, email address and feel free to comment. It would also be a great help if you forwaded the link to this page to other Asgard supporters. Thanks for your support.

To share more thoughts on the Asgard you can join Afloat's online forum here

Other Asgard posts:

thanks-for-the-memories

tenders-sought-for-asgard-salvage

thanks-for-the-memories

asgard-ii-upright-on-the-seabed-and-salvageable

why-we-need-asgard-ii

asgard-sinks-off-french-coast

Comments (1322)

Daithi Byrne said:

... well done Afloat. Raise her Willie!

January 27, 2009

Noel Davidson said:

Raise the Asgard Asgard 2 is a unique Vessel, not just a museum piece but a working vibrant ship. As an ambassador for Ireland she had no equal, a sail training ship giving young and not so young a taste of maritime history. She is lying upright, Rigging still intact, she is insured which will cover the cost of salvage and refurb. Why wait until she can be destroyed by fishing nets and Biscay storms??? Act now ! Please! Noel Davidson

January 27, 2009

PaddyBoyd said:

Raise the Asgard Minister, do not add to the litany of government neglect of our maritime heritage. Sign the contract for her salvage now. Paddy Boyd

January 27, 2009

Gerry Burns said:

Raise the ASGARD 2 This wee Brigantine has flown our flag with pride everywhere she went Australia, America and all over Europe. We had the biggest ensign (tricolour) in the fleet on the 26th January 1988 on Australia's 200th Birthday and Lady Diana even wore a matching green dress that day as we sailed past her. This is no ordinary ship. She has forged countless life-long friendships across the world an gave the first taste of salt to many of our Merchant Navy, Military Navy and international sailors. She draws a crowd and a heart-warming smile wherever she goes. Willie, lift her up where she belongs and show the people of Ireland that love means more than money. Gerry Burns

January 27, 2009

Tony Heffernan said:

Salvage the Asgard II The Asgard II has Proudly represented our country & our maritime hertitage over many a year, and she can do again. Her salvage must be undertaken.

January 27, 2009

Tim O Shea said:

... Mr O'Dea like everything in Ireland at present you have missed the boat.The very violent storm that passed through Biscay last weekend has probably damaged Asgard beyond repair.If this is the case do not leave sail training die in Ireland. As a temporary measure use the insurance money to purchase and refit this vessel "Lady Ellen" topsail schooner 146' €2.9 million asking price, Sweden, steel hull built 1982. see yachtworld.com. This vessel could be on duty for May 2009 if you have the commitment and will to do so and a further bonus no extra cost to the taxpayer. Go Willie Go. It gives the country time to design and build a proper replacement for Asgard II.

January 27, 2009

Andy McDonald said:

Mr. Nuff said. It should be obvious, but as usual, where its needed most, courage is often wanting. Oh go on. You know it makes sense.

January 27, 2009

Ben Garvey said:

... This one's from Nova Scotia, Canada. After witnessing time and again the incredible transformation of youth that took place on a daily basis aboard that fine vessel; after working for 4 summers in the Irish Sail Training community; and after making life-long friendships with the professional and talented leaders and participants in that community - I am saddened beyond words that the vessel should have been left for so long in such a harsh area. There are many larger countries with deeper pockets that have taken notice of - and yearned for - the Asgard program and the vessel itself. It was truly a jewel in Irelands Crown. As many folks have noted, the time to act was months ago. The neglect shown by the decision makers involved does an ugly disservice to the tens of thousands of people - Irish and otherwise - who have been captured by the spirit and intent of the Asgard operation. However - until there is evidence that damage beyond repair has in fact been done to the hull - you MUST proceed immediately with plans to raise the vessel. Mr O'Dea, there is still a chance to bring hope back here, to recover and rekindle what has been lost. Get it done, sir.

January 28, 2009

Dr Ken McCulloch said:

Salvage Asgard It is deeply ironic that shortly after we published the first international study of sail training, and showed the unequivocal benefits of such work, that Asgard was lost. As a national sail training vessel she is important not just in Ireland but in the international; sail training community. She should be raised and restored. The University of Edinburgh January 2009

January 28, 2009

John Daly said:

Asgard II A ship that always boxed well above her weight in international circles. A symbol of our Nation throughout the world.

January 28, 2009

Greg Costelloe said:

... Had the pleasure of sailing on the Asgard II in 1989 and I hope my kids will have the chance too in the future. Please recover this vessel!

January 28, 2009

Emmet Duffy said:

... Please bring her back up. Was on the Asgard in 1987 and 1988. I am hoping my boat mad son will get a chance when he gets a little older.

January 28, 2009

Ruairi Byrne said:

Asgard symbolises the economy...on the bottom but still made of good stuff Dear Minister, In many ways the whole Asgard episode coincided with the sinking economy . Wouldn't it be great if we could refloat both?

January 28, 2009

Paul Clandillon said:

Mr. Please do not allow this fine vessel to be lost as her worth to Ireland and Ireland's reputation is inestimable.

January 28, 2009

Patricia Clandillon said:

Mrs. Please raise this fine vessel which will help to repair our tarnished reputation in difficult times!

January 28, 2009

Arthur Rumball said:

Raise the Asgard! Raise this great ship! They're all a bunch of wallies if they don't!!

January 28, 2009

Clive Sheppard (Sandhurst, UK) said:

... Come on Irish Government, there is insurance money to hopefully pay for the lift, the ship is relatively intact, save a part of your valuable heritage and get Asgard II back in commission again. You guys are always unique if understated unlike our somewhat precious government who couldn't agree together to open the window to get rid of a bad smell. Come on the Irish!!!

January 28, 2009

ian jackson said:

Agree Just let's do it.

January 28, 2009

Nick Gates said:

Asguard II One cannot underestimate the benefit of going to sea as the crew of a ship. It may be a cliche, but take a boy to sea and retun a man. One only has to look at the postings on You Tube from her crew to see the impact she has made on them. At 30 odd years old she is not even half way through her life. Raise her, refit her, and send her back to sea!

January 28, 2009

Tony Brown said:

... It makes a lot sense to raise the Asgard. It appears that any alternative will cost more. Why waste any more time?

January 28, 2009

Jim Manning said:

Raise the Asgard There should be no question. Don't hang around any longer, Raise The Asgard!

January 28, 2009

Jordan Ely said:

... Wake up to what this country is! It is astounding that our maritime heritage, past and present, can be so comprehensively and fatally ignored. Please raise Asgard. If you have ANY pride in being part of Ireland - an island in the Atlantic. And if you have ANY respect for the fact that you were elected to public office to REPRESENT the Irish people.

January 28, 2009

Julia Baer said:

... As a non-national living in Ireland for the past decade and having sailed on the fantastic West Coast / seen the Asgard - it seems outrageous that she is being left on the bottom to become damaged when the enthusiasm, finances and ability is there to raise her! Do it!

January 28, 2009

Antoin Carroll said:

National Pride It is a national disgrace to see the inaction regarding her. Regardless of any economic conditions, Asgard represents irish pride. Our small country has produced maritime greats, John Holland, William Brown, Tom Crean, Ernest Schackleton to name a few. For the sake of our proud Maritime heritage, take her out of the political arena and make a decision. Either raise Asgard or give us closure on the affair by letting us move quickly on a process to create a successor to this national treasure.

January 28, 2009

MossyShanahan said:

Asgard Minister o Dea.Prove the public wrong and show us that this Government is not a Chocolate Fire Guard ! USELESS !!!!!!!!!! RAISE THE ASGARD PLEASE

January 28, 2009

Gillian Fletcher said:

A committed sailor I totally agree with the sentiments of the letter to Minister O'Dea. With health care in hte country in a total mess we cannot afford to lose Asgard or the contribution she has made to Irish Society particularly in helping kids from under privilaged backgrounds to find some pride & confidence in them selves. Gillian

January 28, 2009

John Crebbin said:

... A bungling incompetent an wholly inappropriate Ministry is overseeing the death of Irish sail training. Prove me wrong!

January 28, 2009

Donncha said:

... just get her back up.

January 28, 2009

David Branigan said:

Minister O'Dea The Asgard project has provided an invaluable experience for Irish people from all walks of life, has been a worthy 'flagship' for our country and unites a diverse marine community. Please let this valuable work continue and authorise the recovery of Asgard II before the opportunity is lost forever.

January 29, 2009

Johnny Smullen said:

... please save the asgardand keep some of our heritage alive, as a 16 year old back in '81 I sailed on her and still have the memories and friends I met back then,

January 29, 2009

Brian Roche said:

LIFT HER! They put a man on the moon....and this ain't rocket science....JUST LIFT HER

January 29, 2009

Geoff O'Connor said:

Ascard II Just bring her, how hard can that be ...

January 29, 2009

Ken Powell said:

Unbelievable Unbelievable that this ship could be left on the bottom!

January 29, 2009

Graham H Smith said:

asgard saver It's a small cost to save part of our maritime heritage.

January 29, 2009

Philip Watson said:

... The Government have the insurance money for her loss. It would be a travesty if this money is not used to at least raise the Asgard, even if the refurbishment has to be postponed until we put some more money in their coffers.

January 29, 2009

Ivan Nelson said:

Dr If she is not damaged beyond repair, then raise her, repair her and put her back into commission. In the meantime there is the Jeanne Johnson and what about the Dunbrody? If Asgard is beyond repair, then purchase a vessel already in commission. Oh, someone above mentioned Irish sailors of renown...don't forget Henry Blackwood and Admiral Beaufort of the wind scale!

January 29, 2009

deanemcelree@gmail.com said:

Raise the Asgard. We cannot let the Asgard lie at the bottom of the sea, she represents all that is best in Ireland. The hopes of our young people the spirit of adventure, our desire to explore the world and appreciate its beauties in a sustainble way. We are an island nation but we do not turn our back to the sea, we welcome it is an avenue to the world. Asgard now lies on the seabed, let her rise with the hpoes of our nation. Deane McElree

January 29, 2009

Brian McDowell said:

... Bet they spent the insurance money of new Mercs for Brian Cowan and his cabinet buddies.

January 29, 2009

Dermot Boyle said:

... Raising her appears to be the fastest and most cost effective way of filling the Asgard II sized gap in sail training, plus you save the heritage of this unique vessel - there is no time to waste!

January 29, 2009

Colm O Raghallaigh said:

Mr Minister, do what is right in this case. The money is small and the return on investment will be huge for many generations.

January 29, 2009

Bobby Kerr said:

Mr The Asgard should be raised. The goverment continue to waste money at all levels in our country and the Asgard represents something positive about Ireland which is now going to be lost. Please reconsider. Bobby Kerr

January 29, 2009

Peter Cullen said:

... The Asgard must be raised and restored to her former glory. She has represented the best aspects of Ireland on voyages to far off countries. Asgard is like a roving Ambassador for our country and the cost of raising the vessel and its restoration would be small in comparison to its loss to the Nation.

January 29, 2009

Burke corbett said:

... The insurance money is well gone by now so get Fas to lift it they have what it needs manpower and money it seems.

January 29, 2009

Paul Riordan said:

Dr I think it is a shame for our country that this boat should rest at the bottom of the sea when it is feasible to lift her.

January 29, 2009

Penno said:

Lift Now !! Get her lifted now - we can always refit at our leisure

January 29, 2009

Peter Wolfe said:

Mr Minister, You have a golden opportunity to show leadership and vision in the face of the current economic turmoil and negativity. Restoring the Asgard to service would cost very little in national terms but would symbolise the resolve and tenacity we as an island nation have for recovery from disaster. We will not be beaten by this sinking of our Asgard as we will not be beaten into unending recession. You can significanlty help restore confidence and national pride through this wonderful and positve project. Handled properly in the media you will raise the Asgard , raise our confidence and raise your own esteem among your people. I and many others are at your call to assist and mange the project. Give us the tools and we will do the work. Peter Wolfe

January 29, 2009

Paul Ó Riain said:

Symbolic Representation of this Governments total incompetence The attitude, delaying and lack of communication from our so called government is, I believe, consistent with everything else it has done in the recent past. A total cock up!

January 29, 2009

James Brennan said:

Owner It would be a shame to let this piece of Irish history dissappear.A decesion needs to be made asap.

January 29, 2009

Ciaran Mulloy said:

sailor Let the raising and restoration of the Asgard II be a symbol of the restoration of country after losing the plot in the property bubble. Marine activity can be a source of great pride, pleasure and real wealth. Message to present government: Don't fumble the ball on this one, just do it!

January 29, 2009

Riccardo Schmutz said:

Politics & Heritage ....will this be another instance where heritage and history will be set aside because of political expediency and economics? Great legacy to leave to the future generations!

January 29, 2009

John Gillivan said:

... All Should Get Asgard Raised Definitely

January 29, 2009

Carmel E. Winkelmann said:

... The depth of my volunteer work spans over 40 years My interest in the young is as strong today as in the beginning when my drive was focused on junior training. As a key member of the Irish Sailing Association (ISA) Junior Organizer Committee, which helped shape and develop the ISA Training Schemes, I was closely involved in promoting the first ISA Junior Training Course in the National Yacht Club way back in 1967. My passion for the development and promotion of ISA Training Schemes ensures that many of today’s hot shots first put their foot in the water via programmes I helped to pioneer. In 2007 my commitment to training of the young was recoginised by the Department of Arts, Sport and Tourism, as I was one of eight who received National Awards for our commitments to our sports. So many of these trainees further developed their off shore skills on both Asgards One and Two. Mr. O'Dea is my life's work now at the bottom of the sea with our beloved Asgard

January 29, 2009

Ian McCormack said:

Sailor and lover of the sea Dear Minister, To view the Asgard under full sail, with the banner sized Tri-colour proudly flying above the stern, powering down the River Lee, past Passage West, Gelnbrook, Monkstown, Cobh and Haulboline,is a sight to behold and not to be forgotten. This is also true of other ports and harbours around the world. In these times of global downturn, you should get a better price from the salvage companies for raising the Ship. The country needs an uplift, and what better symbol than to uplift the Asgard. Yours pleadingly Ian.

January 29, 2009

Gabriele Haefs said:

no further comment No further comment, just raise the ship!

January 29, 2009

Vivion P Kennedy said:

Do the Right Thing That this appeal is here at all is indicative of the way this country is run. Would any other country allow the pride of their sailing fleet to rot on the sea bed, when salvage is possible? Unbelievable!

January 29, 2009

catharine ennis said:

... Ireland needs to focus on its youth now more than ever - it was the quality of our young popluation that led us out of the last recession. The Asgard II and the sail training programme has been proven to have an immnse proitive influance on youth devloment. The investment is realtively small for the positive benefits that are yielded.

January 29, 2009

Denise said:

... We can not give up such an assist for are young people

January 29, 2009

patricia and ciaran said:

raise the asgard now Please raise our favourite ship so she can sail again and give so much pleasure to so many people for years to come

January 29, 2009

John P Lynch said:

... I sailed on Asgard II in 1983. even now, 25 years later, it has left me indelible memories. The next geenration should have the same opportunity. The insurers will pay - please raise the Asgard.

January 29, 2009

Damein Byrne said:

Raise It Raise It

January 29, 2009

Eoin Bourke said:

Emeritus Prof. Dr. It would be extraordinary if a government led by Fianna Fáil, the Republican Party, should disregard such a request. I hope it won't.

January 29, 2009

Jerry Dowling said:

... we should cherish the huge contribution the Asgard has given us, as an island nation we should do everything in our power to retrieve her.

January 29, 2009

M Mulcahy said:

... Raising the Asgard II would have incredible symbolic significance for those trying to raise their game (and their hearts) in these uncharted and difficult times. There is only one window - this spring - don't let it pass! The skills do not remain to ever replace this vessel . . seize the moment!

January 29, 2009

Mark White said:

CEO Nowcasting International Asgard must be raised and sail training continued. How many times must it be said - we are an island nation - We have very limited natural resources and the sea is the least developed and most neglected (wantonly). There can be no excuses - get on with the job for the benefit of generations of Irish youth and the marine economy.

January 29, 2009

TomO'Brien said:

... The decision to raise Asgard is urgent. She lies in a hostile environment where delay and indecision can only result in her deteriorating to the point where salvage wont be feasible. So come on Minster and let us know what action if any is being considered by your Department.

January 29, 2009

Scott Mackeown said:

... To leave the Asgard on the bottom of the ocean would be a great shame not only for Irish sailing but for Ireland as a whole. The French are watching us from the side lines scratching there heads wondering why no effort has been made by the Irish to save there Natioal sail training Asgard. The Asgard is sitting on the ocean floor perfectly up right with no extra damage done to the hull from the sinking. This in its self is amazing and the longer it is left on the bottom the more of a chance of damage, If the Ascard can be saved then it should be for the people of Ireland. Also the Captain of the Asgard should be given a reward for his seamanship.

January 29, 2009

Derry Nash said:

... Stop stalling, raise it now

January 29, 2009

Dermot Hicks said:

Director I fully agree that Ireland has squandered the Marine. While we must live in hope and optimism I regret to add that I don't expect anything better from the present regime, although I'd really like a surprise.

January 29, 2009

Michael O'Donnell said:

Thoughts on Asgard II; A National Treasure at the bottom of the ocean. Like a large number of people I know who sailed on Asgard II, I was very upset at her loss. It is a credit to all aboard her that noone was hurt. Our thanks must be to the French, for their very speedy reaction to attend the situation. Personally, I sailed with Asgard twice. She was a beautiful lady of the seas - everyone felt safe on her; one knew that she'd take care of you, whatever the sea conditions. Like any girl she wasn’t to be messed with – but she did look after you. She was a terrific emblem for Ireland. Britain may have had the Royal Yacht, the Americans their aircraft carriers, but Asgard was the perfect platform for flying the tricolour abroad for Ireland – she, and especially because of the kids that learned to sail her, was a modest colourful and welcoming ambassador for Ireland. She gave so many kids and those young at heart the experience of a lifetime – teaching them teamwork and courage at sea, all within a short week of being onboard. I will never forget the first time I climbed the mast – so terrifying I had to put my hand on my knee to stop it shaking - but by the end of the trip we were all scurrying up the mast like maritime gibbons. Please bring her back, or rebuild her. It’s got nothing to do with sentimentality. She's priceless to the country – as both an ambassador and for the character-development of our kids. Those kids will have gone onto other activities encouraging more young people to take part in outdoor pursuits etc. You were concerned about the cost about replacing her. Well Asgard was built in the early ‘80s when we had hard economic times too. Replacing her would be a terrific chance to uplift the country – something visible, tangible and off the People. Most of the people who sailed her over the last 25-30 years will support any fund for a new Asgard – no longer school and college kids but working in business etc. She and her replacement is fundamental to this little island and its maritime traditions. Is Mise, Michael O'Donnell

January 29, 2009

Fergal Guilfoyle said:

Get it up Willy Mr Willie, the Asgard has been a very successful project for the country over many years. It will be cheaper to raise it than build a new ship. So it is obvious, get it up Willie. Fergal

January 29, 2009

Sheena McDonald said:

Why is this even up for debate? It's an institution! Most of us here are lucky enough to be sailors, or at least have access to the water, but the Asgard has allowed people from all walks of life to experience life on the sea. I may never set foot on the Asgard but it's tragic to think that those unforgettable experiences are now being snatched away. RAISE IT!!!

January 29, 2009

Paul Kelly said:

Architect The Asgard represents one of our very few imaginative national youth initiatives lets not let it die on the ocean floor - raise the Asgard now.

January 29, 2009

Marc Palmer said:

Raise Asgard II Prove to the Irish People the elected you all into office that you actually have some back bone and balls, and raise Asgard II. Dont do your usual trick, and keep your head in the sand, on top of your ivory tower. Its about time you did something useful for the people.

January 29, 2009

Danny Yates said:

Irelands Heritage Surely our maritime heritage is deserving of greater respect than to allow such a wonderful piece of its past languish and rot. For the benefit of future generations it is essential that the traditions of Irish sail be protected and passed on, Asgard II is essential to this.

January 29, 2009

Fabrice Richez said:

Mr Classic boats are an important part of our heritage, there are already no many left to transmit to our future generation... Pity to let her down as many others.

January 29, 2009

Terence McGrath said:

... This is a large piece of Irish Sailing history and should be saved

January 29, 2009

Alan McGurdy said:

... Why delay, she will detiorate and make the task of refloating her more difficult and costly.

January 29, 2009

Arthur Daly said:

... ...part of Ireland's heritage and a link to Childers, Tyrrells shipyard etc. Should not be regarded simply in terms of financial expense, the facilities provided help the Irish and Ireland to fly the flag, promote business and tourism, give (new or additional) purpose to younger citizens. Benefits difficult to measure but invalueable. Restoration will provide jobs which will save on dole outlay, some of outlay will be recovered in direct taxation, will assist local economy. Do it.

January 29, 2009

Rachel McNicholl said:

... Asgard II was surveyed on the seabed and tenders were sought for salvage in October 2008. What is the latest news? What is holding up the salvage operation? We will be an international disgrace if a real attempt is not made soon to get our only national sail-training vessel up before its condition deteriorates. If the government can't or won't find the money to raise it, it should admit as much promptly. I'm sure a fundraising campaign would kick in rather than let Asgard II fall foul of political ineptitude and dithering.

January 29, 2009

Alan Dooley said:

... I am appalled that Asgard has apparently been abandoned. A raising of Asgard would lift many Irish hearts during these gloomy days, and present an excellent metaphor for the national recovery.

January 29, 2009

David Cagney said:

More than just a boat The exemplary conduct displayed by captain Newport, his crew and his trainees should be honoured by a safe return of Asgard. It is a pity that the spotless record of competancy over 30 years is not being matched by the government currently on watch...

January 29, 2009

Conor said:

... As usual, the irish government is failing to take action on something of importance to irish people. The Asgard II is sitting idle, and will no doubt break down and decay if she is left too long. Meaning that the longer she is left the less likely she'll be salvaged. traditional tall ships are so rare in this country that the idea of allowing one to go to waste, to just dissolve into some shipwreck that will be of no interest to anyone in the future is criminal. TO allow a piece of our heritage to be left behind is more proof (as if we needed it) that our government has not got the ability to deal with issues that are important to this country. Instead they are happy to leave young Irish people without the incredible opportunity that the Asgard provides. The money is there, the desire clearly isn't and the longer we wait the harder it will become and the worse she'll be. Do we really want her to end up with the Asgard I, famously owned by Erskine Childers, ignored and undervalued in some shed in Collins Barracks because no one cares? Shame on Minister O'Dea, and shame on his department. The department of the Taoiseach stated that the burial of the Asgard I at sea, as suggested by our minister for defense, Bobby Molloy, "would be widely regarded as an act of destruction"*. Why is the same fate for the Asgard II not being considered in the same way? *Irish Times website , Tuesday December 30th 2008.

January 29, 2009

Peter Green said:

... Do something right and raise her. Asgard II has done a lot for the youth of this land and deserves better.

January 29, 2009

Roy Sugars said:

Please save our beloved Asgard 2 I have been sailing out of Dun Laoghaire for most of my life, for as long as i can remember the Asgard 2 has been an object of wonder and fantasy. I was fortunat enough to be one of the 10,000 lucky few to have mentioned above to have the honour of sailing on her not once but twice. out of all my extensive sailing experances (Ireland, france, scotland, norway, denmark, The norht of ireland, the east and south coast of the ROI) my time on the asgard is by far the most memerable. The thought of the Asgard 2 being left to rot on the sea bed seriously saddens and even depresses me. she was and still is one of a kind which cannot be let go, as pointed out above if she has infact deteriorated beyond salvage, she most sertainly should be repalced ! along side the Jean Johnston and the Newly constructed viking long Boat the Asgard stands for our rich history, our heratage and our culture built around the sea form the Vickings to present day. this is a culture, heratage, and history that we should be and are very proud of, and should not be let slip into the world of fantasy, myth and memory.

January 29, 2009

John Thompson said:

... I grew up watching Asgard sail in and out of Dublin bay,and once had the chance to take a trip down to Wicklow on her. That opportunity should be there still, so Mr O Dea, for once , make the right decession and put some faith back into the Government, Raise her. I dont mind paying my taxes for that cause instead of supporting the bank to be nationalised.

January 29, 2009

Daniel Becker said:

Raise the Asgard II and our spirits! Let's restore some national pride and do it!

January 29, 2009

Rob O'Leary said:

... Please recover the Asgard II before it it is too late.

January 29, 2009

Sarah McCrann said:

... Please ensure the future of sail training in Ireland

January 29, 2009

Helen Kelly said:

... Please raise the Asgard as she is an important part of our heritage, promoting our country around the world. Never mind, her importance as a sail training vessel.

January 29, 2009

John Kinsella said:

... Asgard 2 is a part of our pride as a nation - even in the present economic climate she is not a luxury. Please do not wait until it is too late to raise her.

January 29, 2009

Michael Moore said:

Raise the Asgard Mo O Dea, it is incumbent on you to do everything in your power to raise Asgard and get her back sailing again. Considering all the bad press your government is getting at the moment, this would be a very positive move by you!

January 29, 2009

Richie Knight said:

Raise her now As soon as possible please or are you deliberately waiting until it is too late ?

January 29, 2009

Michael Doherty said:

Raise or build another Asgard The Asgard has played a major role as an Ambassator for Ireland in her various world travels. Our children need this vessel as a start to their Maritine experience

January 29, 2009

Joe Hill said:

We need the Asgard. We need the Asgard.

January 29, 2009

Gerry Jones said:

... I agree with this letter re Asgard 11. Gerry Jones

January 29, 2009

Almha Lonergan said:

... Mr. O'Dea, I am putting together a book of memories from trips on the Asgard II. I have called for all those who have ever been involved with the Asgard II in any way to contact me on asgardbookofmemories@hotmail.com with their stories, memories and photos. What I should emphasise is that this book is called The Asgard II Book of Memories; VOLUME ONE. I believe you will make the right choice, and sail training will continue in Ireland as strong as ever. What other choice do you have? Surely you do not want to feel in any way responsible for putting a stop to sail training, for depriving future generations of the opportunities some of us have been lucky enough to experience already, and for essentially labelling the work the Asgard II has done both at home and internationally as pointless? No. Raise the ship and restore your country's faith in your ability to lead our Justice Department. Raise the ship, and along with it you will rasie our hopes, our hearts, our dreams.

January 29, 2009

Noel Griffin said:

... Dear Minister, given that the vessel was insured and is in good condition, an attempt should be made to raise her as soon as possible, with no further delays or filibustering excuses from officials in your department. Politically astute yet mischievous commentators might get the feeling that this foot dragging is in the hope that Asgard II deteriorates to an extent where salvage is not an economic proposition. Please make a decision one way or another to either raise her or replace her. The Asgard's contribution to the thousands of young Irish men and women who have trained on her over the years is immeasurable. Given the recent report of her current good condition, time is of the essence and a salvage attempt should be made as soon as possible (ie first break in the current weather). With respect no one will blame you or your department for trying, but the political cost of doing nothing in this island nation with a proud maritime history could be high. This saga is gathering media interest, the vessel is insured, it is time to act, the Irish nation could be forgiven for thinking this paralysis of decision making permeates the entire administration which is worrying in the current economic climate.

January 29, 2009

Ray hunt said:

... A good use of our Tax Euros raise the ship

January 29, 2009

Shane Kennedy said:

Anti-marine Raise this lovely ship, and show that not all in our administration are anti-boats. We had a great heritage until the 70's, since when it has been seriously suppressed by successive governments.

January 29, 2009

Conor Toomey said:

Raise the Asgard Minister, do the right thing and authorise salvage of this fine ship, a key part of our maritime heritage.

January 29, 2009

Bert Moran said:

Raise the asgard Raise it now before its too late

January 29, 2009

stuart musgrave said:

... Minister You got the insurance money that will pay to lift Asgard. Do it now.

January 29, 2009

Michael Sleivn said:

Why wait until its too late? Minister, The logic in delaying the raising of the Asgard is hard to fathom. Viewed from afar, it would appear that you and your officials are hoping that nature or an errant trawler will make it easy to wring your hands, cry crocodile tears and mutter "ochón 's ochón ó". Well its not good enough. Raise it now before its too late. Michael

January 29, 2009

Paul Dunican said:

... Raise in the Name of Bert Moran who is lost with out it

January 29, 2009

Mitchy said:

Bring that baby back. After the travesty that was Bert Moran's selfish sinking of the Asgard2, I implore you to raise this majestic vessel and prominent part of Irish history both modern and old.

January 29, 2009

Maeve said:

Do the right thing and for once do it sooner rather than later. RAISE THE ASGARD II.

January 29, 2009

EDWARD BYRNE said:

... The best reason to raise the Asgard is to find out why she sunk

January 29, 2009

Spup Duff said:

... Nuke the Asgard, Its all berts fault he sank it

January 29, 2009

Alan Beck said:

Raise the Asgard Rise the Asgard before its to late . I spent the best few weeks of my life on her and it is such a shame that at the moment other people will never get to experience what I and thousands more did aboard her!

January 29, 2009

John Post said:

Raise her for all of us. I agree with this letter. Please save our heritage.

January 29, 2009

Mitchy said:

Irish history lost! If the government fail to raise the asgard they will be in effect deny irish people a part of our history and rich heritage.

January 29, 2009

Jenny Needham said:

... Please raise her!

January 29, 2009

Paal Janson said:

What will it take? It’s clearly the will of the people of this island nation that the Asgard 2 be salvaged and returned to her duties afloat. How many times will the Minister of Defence have to be implored to do something before action will be taken? Please don’t let this piece of Irish maritime history lie forever on the seabed.

January 29, 2009

Almha Lonergan said:

error in earlier comment Apologies for the error in my earlier comment. Where I wrote Justice Department I meant to write Defence department. Slip of the mind.

January 29, 2009

Alex Harwood said:

... Raise her.

January 29, 2009

Fiona Hennigan said:

Where is your pride Mr. O' Dea? Is this what you are to be remembered for?? The FF Government who left such a beauty as Asgard II at bottom of ocean, while other countries wonder how our Government could contemplate NOT lifting her. Shame on you Minister. Its not all about Chad or Limerick you know.

January 29, 2009

Pa Finucane said:

... No excuse surely, there is insurance money for this task.

January 29, 2009

EOIN O'BRIEN said:

Keep a bit of Irish pride afloat! Raise this elegant boat. Do it now before it is too late.

January 29, 2009

Richard Tobin said:

... Dont let recession become depression. Raise the boat and give something to future generations.

January 29, 2009

John Mack said:

How many Defence Forces Members have benifited from her.. Sir, Most if not all naval cadets have learned how do their navigation on board her, The Asgard 1 was used by the reserved Naval service. She has a great past please let her have a future.

January 29, 2009

Brian Barry said:

... Minister. The recovery of Asgard II is not a matter of expediency - it is an absolute neccessity. Ireland is an island nation, with a rich history of maritime endeavour,and as such has an obligation to place sail training at the top of the agenda. Too much time has already been lost. YOU MUST ACT NOW!

January 29, 2009

Mal Nowlan said:

Abandon an icon? Asgard is an icon. She lifted hearts of all, seagoers and non-seagoers, as she came into sight. I cannot understand the mindset that could allow her to remain on the bottom. To abandon an icon like her is not clever, especially in these tough times.

January 29, 2009

Sarah Kelleher said:

Please raise the Asgard Its disgrace to have her lying under the water this long. Raise her!

January 29, 2009

Terry Leonard said:

Raise the Asgard Bring it on home

January 29, 2009

Anne Craig said:

... We need Asgard. It is time to stop faffing about and get her up. The money is there to raise her; only then will we know if she really is repairable

January 29, 2009

Fiacc OBrolchain said:

... If you don't give your name to this petition your voice will not be heard. Coiste get on with it

January 29, 2009

james o connor said:

... When will we start taking the sea and all associated issues and opportunities seriously lets not let another maritime issue sit on the bottom.

January 29, 2009

Ryan said:

asgard 2 this is one of the few things the Irish govt managed to get right letting this program sink would be the equivilant of shutting down the IFSC and grant schemes.

January 29, 2009

Ciara Mulrooney said:

Get Her UP! its an absolute disgrace shes still lying there. we need her, an island nation, shes part of who we are. its not a question of if, its a question of when, the answer should be asap.

January 29, 2009

Nigel Allen - Irish Spars and Rigging Ltd said:

Bring The Asgard home Even in difficult financial times like the present money can always be found to do the right thing. I'm sure every boating man in Ireland and abroad would pledge a few coins to stop the loss of this historical vessel,you could not go out and order another one !! In twenty years we'll be saying we should have done something at the time, every week the bill will get bigger!

January 29, 2009

Beth O'Loughlin said:

Ms Please raise this glorious boat.

January 29, 2009

Ronan O'Malley said:

Hope it's not too late. Raise her and bring her home, even if only to dock her.

January 29, 2009

Justin Butler said:

... I sailed on her from Dublin to Lisbon through some horrible weather in the Bay of Biscay. She did her country proud and I was always excited to see her sail into Dun Laoghaire. I agree that sail training must continue to move forward and I fully appreciate the volunteers efforts to maintain the Asgard but maybe it is time to move on and create another fine training vessel. We have the Jeanie Johnston as a sail training vessel at the moment and it cost a lot to put in place. Does any one honestly know just how much it will cost to raise and repair, how it will be funded, and where the work can be done? It will end up going out to tender and could possible end up in a French or English shipyard as they will undercut the Irish yards. She was a beautiful ship but nostalgia has it place. Come on guys, be realistic. Justin

January 29, 2009

willie galvin said:

... An icon, capable of being salvaged, and yet left to rot if no-one shouts stop. Raise the lady!

January 29, 2009

Lisa Kelly said:

... I never sailed on her. I never knew any of her crew. I never even got up close to her but when I saw her, maybe from the Dart window or walking on Dun Laoghaire pier, I knew I loved her. She was Ireland of the high seas. Unmistakable little icon. I want her back. Please.

January 29, 2009

Nici Roechert said:

... the asgard was one of my favourite ships to sail, i made a lot of good friends on her, and she is a dream to sail!! She also is a huge icon for irish kids and the entire country! so willie stop being a muck savage and raise her!

January 29, 2009

Honor O Brolchain said:

Ms This is absolutely essential on so many levels that there should be no hesitation whatever.

January 29, 2009

Aisling said:

... There's enough doom and gloom at the minute - a good news story about raising the Asgard II might be just what we need!

January 29, 2009

Paul Laycock said:

Raise the Asgard Irish sail training needs the Asgard, raise and get the Asgard back to her work ASAP

January 29, 2009

Owen MacCarthaigh said:

Raise our Asgard-----Raise our spirits O Ship of State Thou, too, sail on, O Ship of State! Sail on, O Union, strong and great! Humanity with all its fears, With all the hopes of future years, Is hanging breathless on thy fate! We know what Master laid thy keel, What Workmen wrought thy ribs of steel, Who made each mast, and sail, and rope, What anvils rang, what hammers beat, In what a forge and what a heat Were shaped the anchors of thy hope! Fear not each sudden sound and shock, 'Tis of the wave and not the rock; 'Tis but the flapping of the sail, And not a rent made by the gale! In spite of rock and tempest's roar, In spite of false lights on the shore, Sail on, nor fear to breast the sea! Our hearts, our hopes, are all with thee. Our hearts, our hopes, our prayers, our tears, Our faith triumphant o'er our fears, Are all with thee, -are all with thee! Longfellow

January 29, 2009

Martin Ó Treasaigh said:

... The vessel was insured, the insurance company have agreed to meet the costs of recovering the vessel, so why hasn't she been raised? Political apathy is the only answer. The longer she remains down there, the more difficult and costly here repair and refurbishment will be.

January 29, 2009

diarmuid said:

mr i am young enthuastit sailor and would have liked to sail on the asgard this summer but because it is no longer available i now intend to travel with the tenacious. i think a training vessel is a great asset and this one has a place in the heart of ireland and irish sailors. BRING BACK THE ASGARD!!!!!!!!!!!!

January 29, 2009

Galen Brislane said:

Mr Raise her. I sailed on her in Tall Ships 2000 in Bermuda. Proud as punch to be Irish that day.

January 29, 2009

Donal O'Brolchain said:

citizen Raise the Asgard, Minister!

January 29, 2009

Lorna Finnegan said:

Minister O'Dea - time to become a "dreamer of the day"... make it happen! All men dream, but not equally. Those who dream by night in the dusty recesses of their minds, wake in the day to find that it was vanity: but the dreamers of the day are dangerous men, for they may act on their dreams with open eyes, to make them possible. ~ T.S. Lawrence

January 29, 2009

niamh murphy said:

asgard:D Best week of my life!!

January 29, 2009

Emer Tuohy said:

AZZY AZZY ASGARD pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeease

January 29, 2009

Mahon Carmody said:

Asgard II Standing on the yard-arms of the Asgard II as she sailed through the Garonne Estuary after her victory in the 1991 Tall Ships was one of the greatest moments of my life. My 10 days on the Asgard II changed me from a boy into a man. Please let other young people enjoy this unique possibility to understand what there is to love about the sea. Mahon

January 29, 2009

maddie o connell said:

azzy azzy asgard please recover it!!

January 29, 2009

Dave Ryan said:

Gráinne Ni Mháille, Dont forget Gráinne is down there too, wood and canvas can be fixed. Raise them both Mr O Dea

January 29, 2009

Erin Ryan said:

Asgard Please raise the Asgard so when i grow up my Dad will let me sail on her...

January 29, 2009

Declan Byrne said:

Ministers, Do the right thing!!!!! If Asgard 2 was the French, German or British national sail training vessel, she would have been raised last October. For them it would have been a matter of national pride at stake. Ministers, Banks come and go, recessions come and go but Asgard 2 may be gone and gone forever. And in comparison it will only cost but a drop in the ocean (pardon the pun).

January 29, 2009

Deirdre O Driscoll said:

... What a shame...was such a amazing experience... Please raise the asgard II would love to see her again..

January 29, 2009

Eavan Walsh said:

Bring her home I was lucky enough to sail on the Asgard a few months before she sank. I'm not from a sailing background and the Asgard presented a fantastic opportunity for me to earn my sea-legs. The Asgard II and the sail training experience was a credit to the crew who sailed her. The money is there, in these times of recession don't let a beacon of hope rot.

January 29, 2009

Paddy Doyle said:

Raise the Asgard This ship is too valuable in ever sense of the word to be allowed rot at the bottom of the sea.

January 29, 2009

Paul O'Dwyer said:

Raise the Asgard! Don't let this valuable training resource sit at the bottom of the sea any longer, Minister; raise the Asgard.

January 29, 2009

paul morgan said:

mr Asgard 2 is a unique piece of Irish Maritime history which can never be replicated. It is time for the "waffling" to cease and action to start before we become the laughing stock of the maritime world.

January 29, 2009

Nicholas Bourke said:

Raise the Asgard II As such an important icon, and asset to Ireland the rescue and refit of the asgard II is invaluable. Asgard II was my first ship and led my way to a successful Merchant Navy Career. This is the same for many other persons. For many young people it has given a unique insight into maritime Ireland, and developing friendships and skills invaluable in later life. Raise the Asgard II!!

January 29, 2009

A R Giles said:

Mr If its technically possible and the underwriters approve, why delay, unless there is some hidden agenda!

January 29, 2009

Brian Garvey said:

Dr. I wholeheartedly endorse this petition to raise Asgard and keep Irish Sail training active.

January 29, 2009

Elaine Gilligan said:

... Minister, Ireland needs Asgard back more than ever, with the state of the countires ecomomy Irelands young people need something positive. I have sailed on Asgard many times and have witnessed the remarkable effect this beautiful ship and her crew have had on those young people that most of society would rather turn their back on or lock up. It has changed their lives for the best. This has been proven time and time again. Many young people are now sailing the high seas as a career after finding a love of the sea on Asgard, these kids were destined for a life less fortunate, but meeting other young people from other parts of society has changed their outlook. Where else would you find a doctor, a teacher, an army cadet and a young person who was on their last chance with the law for stealing cars, sharing a love of the sea and drinking tea at 3am whilst crewing our beautiful ship as slips past the sleeping irish coastline. These are the magic life changing moments that Asgard has offered thosands of Irelands young people. It brings people together, unites them, and teaches them that teamwork is the only way to get things done and the each individual person has an important role. Imagine being 16 years of age and you have the wheel of a ship, the pride and self confidence that it gives to that person is immeasurable, I know because that is what sailing on Asgard gave to me, a confidence and understanding that I could do anything if I put my mind to it. Money cannot buy that, only experience can. So Minister it is time act, the young (and the not so young) people need their ship back, and I fail to see a reason why this cannot be done, the rebuilding will bring jobs back to a country that needs it, the re-launching will bring hope and excitement back to a country that is tired of bad news and you could be the one to do it!!Please do not hide behind the excuses of economic hardship etc etc, I am sure if you used the insurance money to raise her, there are several people who would be only too willing to help out to get her back to her former glory...you have no end of volunteers who want to help. It starts with you, do the right thing by the young people!!Bring her back home

January 29, 2009

Barry Mulrooney said:

... Rise her!

January 29, 2009

Clair Burke said:

Raise the Asgard II Having been one of the lucky 10,000 people who got to sail of this beautiful ship on many occasions and also spending lots of my college years doing maintenance weekends in Arklow, Dun Laoghaire & Cork, it saddens me to think of the old lady on the bottom of the sea in France, please Mr O'Dea do whatever it takes to raise her and bring her back to Ireland, so that future generations will have the opportunity that we had over the past 27 years learning to sail on her. Clair Burke Commodore Royal BVI Yacht Club

January 29, 2009

Jim Morrissey said:

... The patter of praise for Asgard II by past and serving Ministers over the years is rendered increasingly hollow as the ship continues to languish, abandoned in French waters. The failure of Dept. of Defence to commission a salvage operation to raise our national sail training vessel in a swift decisive manner is being viewed with disdain and disbelief by the French and other European maritime neighbours, as well as many Irish people for whom Asgard was an Icon. End the shameful waiting and indecision, utilise the vessel's insurance for its rightful purpose, and make haste all hands to assist a vessel in trouble.

January 30, 2009

A Lost at sea Sailor said:

Sir, You have the money. Sir, four barracks closed, Chad costing est4 million per tour of duty 1. There has to be savings if the barracks/posts are closed.. ie ESB, Fuel, selling of the land etc. 2. tChad is due to be taken over by a UN mandate in March/April so it will no longer be a EUFOR mission which means that you won't have the full expense of mission.. 3. There was a fund set up to refloat Asgard (Asgard 1 Erskine Childers boat) she still isn't in the water so those funds are in a bank account somewhere. The ship herself is in Collins Barracks Dublin and that restoration can be put on hold. 4. Wasted peace across the border money on the Donbrody* if she doesn't leave the quays in Dublin. Spend the money on what we the people want. 5. How many disadvantage teens from your voting constitute were given the chance to sail on her and as a result have made positive changes to their life. 6. Arrangements can be made for the Asgard II to visit Limerick City..

January 30, 2009

sinead nic giollapharaic said:

raise the asgard

January 30, 2009

Mick J Byrne said:

Captain As a national icon, this ship holds as much significance to the Irish people as the QE2 does to the British. It would be of even more significance if she was sailing again or laid up somewhere as a historical icon, having been raised from her current location. The last thing we want is our future generations of officers looking at an Irish wreck on an Admiralty chart in foreign waters.

January 30, 2009

Mary Buckley said:

mrs I saw and admired this beautiful ship and was so shocked at it's loss. We need it back for our pride.

January 30, 2009

Gerry Tierney said:

... Do the right thing - raise Asgard II

January 30, 2009

Paul Hogan said:

Mr Get her up, time is surely running out the longer she lies there the worse she will be. Raise the Asgard please!!!!!!!!!

January 30, 2009

Albert o Sullivan-Geene said:

Love that ship!! Raise the Asgard!!!!

January 30, 2009

Cormac Gebruers said:

Asgard II: Part Ireland's Maritime Heritage Tough economic times or not, the Asgard II is simply too important a symbol, too important a ship and too important a part of our maritime heritage to be left on the seabed.

January 30, 2009

Captain Michael McCarthy said:

President of the Irish Institute of Master Mariners. Commercial Manager Port of Cork The Asgard 11 has played a very important role in providing young Irish people with an opportunity of experiencing time at sea. This has opened their eyes to the importance of the sea to an island nation. Many have gone on to a career at sea and many of the Harbour Masters and Pilots in our ports and Officers serving in the Merchant Navy and Naval Service had their first seagoing experience on Asgard 11. The delay in raising the vessel has undoubtly resulted in additional damage, nevertheless ,she should be immediately surveyed and raised if feasable depending on the quantum of damage and recovery costs.

January 30, 2009

Fiodhna Horan-Murphy said:

raise the asgard just do it.

January 30, 2009

Sam Corbett said:

Maritime Venue Designers This is REDICULOUS! Why do we continue to allow 'ministers' to work in roles that they have NO experience or interest in? (look at Harney!) One word springs to mind: INCOMPETANCE. Get the finger out!

January 30, 2009

Simon Long said:

Why is the Minister stalling ? I can understand that it may be a difficult time of year to raise her with the Winter weather. However I cannot understand why the Minister just makes the descision to do it anyway and get the wheels in motion. Surely she is insured anyway so it's not as if its going to break the country! If they leave her down there with no good reason it will be an absolutely shameful act of political short sightedness.

January 30, 2009

Clare Ryan said:

Let the Asgard raise her sails once more - raise her while we can No more time should be delayed. I want so much to see her -the Asgard- again, to walk on the deck, climb up the rigging and listen once more to Kev's -the cook- incredible stories about his life on the seas. I was only with her for 8 days but she has had such an impact on my life. I wont forget the first time standing on the yard-arms when she was away from the docks. The wind and sun were out in force and I can remember just trying to untie the sails in time with the rocking of the ship as she drove through the water. I hope also not just for our sake that she is raised but for future generations and of course, most importantly, for the permanent crew members both present and past to whom the Asgard was a huge part of their lives. During the brief and memorable time I sailed with her, the Asgard was my home, the crew my family and my fellow trainees my friends. I hope she joins us soon to lift her sails once more.

January 30, 2009

Paul Edward Roche said:

Captain The Asgard II is part of our maritime heritage. To allow it to rot on the seabed is a travesty for a maritime nation.

January 30, 2009

Cormac O'Dwyer said:

... Raise the Asgard.

January 30, 2009

Jamie Young said:

Owner Killary Adventure Company Time to rise!

January 30, 2009

David Carmody said:

Mr. My son and his cousins have valuable and memorable of sailing on Asgarg. She is literally a Flagship for Ireland. David Carmody

January 30, 2009

Brendan O'Connor said:

... Bring her home!

January 30, 2009

susan roundtree said:

... We want Asguard raised and back as our sail training vessel

January 30, 2009

Elaine Cunningham said:

... raise the Asgard

January 30, 2009

Mark Costelloe said:

... Anyone who was fortunate enough to have seen this beautiful boat in full sail or even resting beside the Quay will know exactly why it is important to return her to her former glory. It's time to raise her before its too late

January 30, 2009

Colm Walsh said:

Mr. Sailing is part of our national heritage and The Asgard is a big part of that, bring her back!

January 30, 2009

Dermot Durack said:

... Asgard was a great ambasador for teh country and should be raised before it is too lte

January 30, 2009

PETER VINE said:

Trustee of OCEANSWATCH www.oceanswatch.org

January 30, 2009

Karen Isaac said:

Riase the Asgard Many a happy cruise spent about The Asgard II - many happy memories, and many great friends made... it will be a shame to deprive others of the same memories... get her Raised before it is too late....

January 30, 2009

siobhan mullen said:

life the lady lift the lady. asgard has been around for goodness knows how long and is something very important for young and old sailers everywhere...let her sail!!!!!!!

January 30, 2009

Fiona Cassidy said:

... Asgard II provided inspiration and hope to so many of us during the last recession Please don't let her become a casualty of this one Raise her now

January 30, 2009

Eamonn Doyle said:

... For as long as ASGARD is allowed to lay on the seabed she will remain a potent symbol of a dithering and sinking administration.

January 30, 2009

william Patterson said:

Peerage (pending) If it is at all possible, she should be raised - in this economic climate I am sure someone with the equipment would be glad of the job at a lower-than-usual rate.

January 30, 2009

Michael O'Brien said:

... Raise the Asgard

January 30, 2009

Dermot Carmody said:

... Ireland, pick up your stuff off the floor when you drop it, there's a good lad.

January 30, 2009

Emer O'Reilly said:

French Govt to assist? Which one of us is going to lift the phone to the French Ambassador and ask him for French Naval assistance for the lift?

January 30, 2009

william Patterson said:

When this is over......... ................what will people think of our Minister and our Country ................. there are some things that economists should not be allowed to give an opinion on............ Asgard is one of these

January 30, 2009

Susie Elliott said:

... And we wonder why we are becoming known as the "throwaway nation"???? Prove them wrong, lift our old ship and bring her back to her former glory.

January 30, 2009

Hugh W. Mockler said:

... Dear Minister, "Asgard 11" has been a tremendous Ambassador for Ireland. She has had a great tradition of bringing people from all walks of life to sail and work together. That tradition must be allowed to continue. Please bring her back to life.

January 30, 2009

Andy O'Neill said:

Hey Minister Raise the Asgard !

January 30, 2009

Stephen Clark said:

Are you too grand for the people? Do you want to try to preserve sailing for the rich and privileged, keep the "rif raf" out, or do you think it should be available to everyone on this island, to learn the shared endeavour of ship-mates, the shared achievement of teamwork and the beauty of our island and maritime heritage??? Asgard has an important role to play.

January 30, 2009

michael prior said:

retired C.S. Please, Minister, do not let us spend precious and irretrievable time on establishing the "price" of recovery without proper regard to the true value of restoring Asgard II to her once widely admired role as the pioneer of sail training in Ireland. The above sentiment is even more valid in times of economic hardship when the contribution of character is more important than cash resources

January 30, 2009

Paul Jones said:

... Dont dissapoint A lOT of poeple

January 30, 2009

Mairéad Lineen said:

... hurry up before it's too late...

January 30, 2009

H Bleakley said:

... If the Government can bail out the banks with OUR money, bail out the Bacon industry and not bail out the Asgard II they need not be surprised if they are baled up with the chaff and other rubbish at the next General election. Raise her now.

January 30, 2009

D. Hartigan said:

Minister That vessel has been a strong part of our national sail training past, representing Ireland in many tall ship events. Please raise her, and bring her home!

January 30, 2009

Lawrence Kilbane said:

Mr It cant be that hard to raise her. In the summer of 2008 a team from Boskalis Dredging and Salvage moved a WW1 U Boat from the North East lane of the Dover straits. All it takes is a liitle imagination and a lot of will power. Sadly this is lacking in official Ireland some of whom forget that we are an Island Nation. Mise le meas Lawrence Kilbane.

January 30, 2009

Roisin Lonergan said:

... To allow the Asgard 11 to remain on the seabed in the Bay of Biscay is a crime. This relatively small Tall Ship has taught thousands of young and not so young people how to work as part of a team, how to pull together to get a job done and has brought honour and good publicity to this country for many years. Raise the Asgard and allow thousands more to experience a learning holiday beyond comapre.

January 30, 2009

maurice daly said:

... Surely they can manage to refloat the Asgard, even if they have sunk the economy...................

January 30, 2009

William Moran said:

Mr. In times of recession and national depression the sight of Asgard being resurrected and sailing into Irish harbours would raise national spirits.

January 30, 2009

Joan Murphy said:

... I experienced the Asgard as both a Trainee and a Watchleader, it has helped to develop me to be the person I am today. I and many others the same have fond memories of the Agard, and the thing that sadens me the most is that others will not be as fortunated to experience the same. Thank you, Joan Murphy

January 30, 2009

Andrew Robinson said:

Worth saving The work that went into Asgard II was, I gather, of exceptionally high standard, worth saving before the sea dismantles her completely.

January 30, 2009

Ronan Kenny said:

its time It's finally time for wille to grow a pair of balls...he has to make a decision on the asgard...each day he waits to decide on wether or not to raise the vessel is costing him in the long run....make the decision wille...show you have balls!

January 30, 2009

Patrick Farrell said:

Come on Ireland! Come on the Government, it can't be left at the bottom of the sea! We would do it ourselves if we had the resources!

January 30, 2009

Steve Conlon said:

Dear Minister O'Dea Asgard II has not only been a superb Ambassador for Ireland providing a National presence at many events around the world but has also served Ireland well in its intended function by providing sail training to a huge cross section of Irish people, young and old. With the continuing neglect of our maritime heritage and the total lack of any maritme policy, Asgard II was the only bright light on a dismal shore. With this light extinguished, is this the end of any maritme future for Ireland, an island nation? To reassure us that this Government does have some maritime policy please lift Asgard II and reinstate the vessel immediately.

January 30, 2009

Captain Morvan Le Dorven said:

... I am a professional Merchant Navy Officer and have an excellent career at this difficult economic time, this is due in part to the Asgard II. Lets do the right thing and raise the emblem of Irish Sailing. Best Regard Captain Morvan Le Dorven

January 30, 2009

Alan Turner said:

Mr

January 30, 2009

Aidan Fleming said:

.. Only people who have sailed aboard a sail training vessel will know the true benefits of the experience gained and character building qualities that can be achieved from such a trip. Asgard II has been responsible for many career changing decisions not only in the maritime sector but in all types of industry. There must be some sort of benefit in the system when organisations such as AIB, Aer Lingus to name but a few chose Sail Training as a medium for team building. Failure to raise the vessel will wipe out any chance many people, young and old, will have of getting more out of life.

January 30, 2009

John Judge said:

... It's a crying shame to have something as unique and well loved as our sail training vessel sitting on the sea floor with her future unknown

January 30, 2009

Pat Lonergan said:

... This is a no-brainer. For the sake of her past - and her future - Asgard has to "rise again - that her name not be lost to the knowledge of men". What are you waiting for?

January 30, 2009

Tristan Fouere said:

Mr. Its important that the next generation have the same opportunities we had. It would be a terrible shame to allow our maritime heritage to suffer by forgetting the Asgard. Save the Asgard.

January 30, 2009

Holly Byrne said:

Miss. minster, look at the signings so far... think of all those who have sailed her over the years and enjoyed the experince of sailing the waters on her. it would heart breaking for all throughout the country and crush the hopes of those who hadnt sailed of ever doing so. it was devasating to watch her go down that night, but i had the hope that she will be raised and continue for decades more to sail the waters, worldwide. please dont let that hope of mine and the nations sink with the Asgard II!!

January 30, 2009

Colm Duffy said:

... Raise the Asgard.

January 30, 2009

sam said:

sunken treasure lift the Asgard II before we lose her.

January 30, 2009

Isolde McNicholl Motley said:

From New York My American sons learned to sail here on the Hudson River with the promise that when they were old enough, they could crew on the Asgard. Please show what Ireland can do; bring her up.

January 30, 2009

afloat.ie said:

... http://www.afloat.ie/news/deci...asgard-ii/

January 30, 2009

Alan Fleury said:

... lift the Asgard II before its to late

January 30, 2009

Tom Gelletlie said:

... ........

January 30, 2009

Ronan Moore said:

Raise the Asgard This vessel has played a vital role in getting young people to work together and understand what life is all about. Communication, trust and confidence are all necessary to ensure the smooth running of a ship. This vessel has brought people from every walk of life together and made them understand that at the end of the day life is what it is and nobody should be allowed to think they are better than anyone else. Raise this valuable asset minister and make this nation proud again.

January 30, 2009

Gillian Martin said:

Raise the Asgard I am signing the petition to raise the Asgard given the role she has played as an ambassador over the years, and the role she will play in the coming years.

January 30, 2009

Paul Harrison said:

Mr Raise the Asgard.

January 30, 2009

Louise Kennedy said:

Asgard II Don't leave such a big part of Irish history at the bottom of the ocean!

January 30, 2009

John Brennan said:

bring her back up! Bring her back up!

January 30, 2009

Wattie said:

... Asgard represented Ireland and Irish people, past present and future with dignity and grace. Do the right thing and give us back something to be proud of in these troubled times. Raise our nations spirits, Raise the Asgard.

January 30, 2009

DAMIAN RUBY said:

Mr ASGARD II SHOULD BE BACK ON THE WATER IN IRELAND, CERTAINLY NOT BELOW THE WAVES IN FRANCE !!!

January 30, 2009

Cáit Mc Enery said:

Ms Its so sad to think of her at the bottom of the ocean.. bring her back

January 30, 2009

Gareth Craig said:

... Bring Asgard back to where she belongs, pride of place at the head of our national fleet. She has done so much for everyone who has stood on her deck or climbed her rigging that she must NOT be allowed to break up at the bottom of the Bay of Bisque!

January 30, 2009

Bartley Fannin said:

... The Asgard has introduced so many people to the sea and the joys of Sailing. It is important for this Maritime country that it continues to do so - Raise the Asgard!

January 30, 2009

Steve Palmer said:

Our National Treasure. Asgard II Asgard is as much a part of the Irish Soul and Identity as The Ardagh Chalice or The Book of Kells. We cannot just walk over her and forget. Does our Government realize just how Asgard has served her country? Not only in encouraging and developing youth potential but also as a valuable ambassador abroad. She is always the centre of attraction at any International event and I’d venture that her very presence does as much for Ireland as trade delegations or advertising. We have the benefit of hindsight here. We already know her history. We therefore know her value. We must save her.

January 30, 2009

niamh-anouk dekker said:

.... had the best expirience of my life sailing on the asgard 2! i hope its brought up it should be sailing not at the bottem of the sea in france raise the asgard!!

January 30, 2009

fi fi fi fi o connor said:

i love this boat it could be made legal...wink raise her

January 30, 2009

maeve bradley said:

Asgard- why oh why please raise her. i need to prove i am worthy

January 30, 2009

DaisyBell said:

raise her up. The Asgard is something unique to Ireland and needs to be raised back up and given a second lease of life. It has been good to the country and taught many young people the art of sailing properly, so raise her to the surface.

January 30, 2009

David McCann said:

Mr Don't leave it too long

January 30, 2009

Kyle O'Regan said:

Raise her! For the memories, for the growing up, for the fiends. Raise her.

January 30, 2009

Ian Heffernan said:

... As an Island Nation you'd think we would have a proud and strong maritime tradition, all we realy had was the Asgard and now she is languishing at the bottom. The Minister must realise there is more to a nation than an economy? At a fraction of the cost of a new sail training vessel the government could restore some faith in their character and in the process ensure the memories and dreams of countless people don't lie waste in the waters off Biscay. If the Asgard was a bank perhaps she would have been "bailed out" in a more timely fashion.

January 30, 2009

Antoin Daltún said:

... Ardaigh ár long! Ardaigh ár meanma!

January 30, 2009

Ray Macken said:

... Just do it

January 30, 2009

Simon Hedderman said:

... Lift her before someone else does...

January 30, 2009

Donal Keane said:

Minister O'Dea The longer you wait the harder it will get. Just get on with it and let her get floated again.

January 30, 2009

Maria Stacey said:

... Raise the asgard!!

January 30, 2009

Aoife said:

... Raise the Asgard! You can't leave her there, it's like turning your back on our Sail Training programme. Raise the Asgard.

January 30, 2009

Olivia Van Walleghem said:

... Breaks my heart to think that the ship that i'd such fun and have such fond memories of is submerged under the uisce.. hope this little email goes a long way towards saving our national treasure

January 30, 2009

Stiofán O Connor said:

... Save the Asgard!

January 30, 2009

niamh keane said:

... raise it up!! need a second chance to prove that i actually can hoist a sail.

January 30, 2009

John H. Luxton said:

... ASGARD II was a regular visitor to Liverpool for tall ships events. Get the lady raised now whilst she is still salvageable. John Luxton www.irishseashipping.com Liverpool

January 30, 2009

Michael Flanagan said:

... Raise the Asgard.

January 30, 2009

Alan Mooney said:

Raise the Asgard The pride of every port she ever visited! It is of absolute importance that she be raised to carry on this tradition!!

January 30, 2009

Deirdre Ní Chonchubhair said:

... Save the Asgard! Please! Please! Please! I REALLY want to sail on it! I was too young to sail on it until last year and then what happened? It sank!! Come on it has to be salvaged! NOW!!

January 30, 2009

Rory Keane said:

... Raise her up asap. We need a ship of her calibre to continue sail training and raising Asgard is the best option.

January 30, 2009

ConorKennedy said:

Watch Leader Come on Willie, This has been a wonderful Institution. Raise the Asgard II and let our Children enjoy the spirit of this wonderful vessel.

January 31, 2009

ConorKennedy said:

Raise the Asgard II What would poor old Eric Healy have thought of his Lady lying on the seabed??

January 31, 2009

Luke Aherne said:

Keep the traditions alive keep the traditions alive not just for us, but for our children and for the generations to come.

January 31, 2009

desmond beatty said:

... Dear Mr. O'Dea Sail training is such a powerful formative experience for young people. Do not let this this strong "ambassador" for Ireland lie at the bottom of Biscay. Please raise the Asgard II. Desmond of Dublin

January 31, 2009

justin perry said:

... indeed. get her up. for everyone who has ever sailed on her and for those who havent had a chance

January 31, 2009

Otto Kunze said:

Mr. Get her up before it is too late!

January 31, 2009

Chris Moss said:

... It needs to be done soon. So get on with it.

January 31, 2009

Mary said:

... Please raise the asgard! It would be such a shame to leave such a beautiful boat at the bottom of the sea, especially one that has taught so many people how to sail!

January 31, 2009

caitriona lynch said:

... Raise the Asgard for all our sakes.

January 31, 2009

Cliodhna Fannin said:

Signing There are too many memories to let it go to waste

January 31, 2009

Aoife Kelly said:

... Raise the Asgard!!

January 31, 2009

Mrs. Winifred Curran said:

Former District Commissioner Scouting Ireland SAI Sceilig District Yes of course the Asgard II should be raised and the sooner the better. Scouts in Kerry have many happy memories of visiting the Asgard II when she visited Dingle.

January 31, 2009

Aoife Macken said:

Raise the Asgard 2 Ireland needs a sail training ship....raise the Asgard before it's too late and too much damage has been done to this beautiful magnificent ship. I've trained on the Asgard and have no hesitation in training on her again once raised.

January 31, 2009

Paul Kirwan said:

... Just do it!

January 31, 2009

Paul Bowen said:

... The opportunity to raise her is slipping away, do not be remembered as the minister who had the chance to save the Asgard and create pride for all irish in doing so, but decided to do nothing!

January 31, 2009

Chris Andrews said:

Friend of the Asgard II I was in Ireland when the Asgard sank and have friend who have sailed on her. I think bringing her to the surface again is a worth endeavour.

January 31, 2009

paddy egan said:

raise the asgard a shame to see our greatest vessel on the sea floor. raise the asgard.

January 31, 2009

Brendan Macken said:

Asgard 11----A National Treasure. Immediate action is urgently needed to complete the survey, and raise Asgard 11, before it is damaged by trawlers etc.Further delay is inexcusable.

January 31, 2009

Jessica Webbley said:

... Please raise the Asgard.

January 31, 2009

Aaron Watson said:

Mr Raiser her, its history!

January 31, 2009

Billy Crowley said:

Deputy Officer In Charge. Irish Coast Guard Bonmahon Unit Dear Mr O Dea..i first sailed ASGARD 2. in 91 since then i saw many changes to the ship and her crew. When i first joined her i was always putting my self down. but i left asgard 2 a CHANGED Person . LIKE ALL THE REST OF THE PEOPLE Who got the chance to sail Our Great SHIP.It changed there lives too. YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT OUR ASGARD DID FOR ALL OF US . THE 10.000 and over who sailad on her. And we always carried ireland high we did more for IRELAND.than any other groupe. We pushed our Country to the last.And many people came to see Ireland Becouse of ASGARD 2. AND Also it did more for SAFTY AT SEA TOO. It gave many many people a under standing of sea safty. Whitch makes our job in.SEARCH and RESCUE easer. SO please M R. O .DEA . Please rase our little ship. SO THAT many many more people. can get a NEW LIFE from our little GREEN SHIP . A.2.. . from billy crowley

January 31, 2009

Stephen Bourke said:

... As one of those fortunate enough to have sailed on the Asgard II, I strongly believe that the Asgard needs to be salvaged or permanently replaced for future trainees.

January 31, 2009

james jagger said:

Raise Her Was on board in Portree. Lovely boat shame to let her rot when the tech is there to save her.

January 31, 2009

Liz Bourke said:

Raise her. Raise her. She's worth it.

January 31, 2009

Stephne Guilmartin said:

To the Govnerment of Ireland, DO something right for once and raise The Asgard II to its former glory. It should belong on the seas and not below it.

January 31, 2009

Catriona Hegarty said:

... I do not know much about this Vessel. but I understand it is very dear to quite a lot of people's hearts. So I would support anything anybody could do to raise her. for future generations I am a Ex crew Member from the QE2/Cunard and I understand the unity when people sail and work together. its the best feeling... So I do hope this once beautiful vessel is raised. and restored to her former Glory. All the best .Catriona

January 31, 2009

Liam Kavanagh said:

Capt If Asgard is found to be in reasonable condition then get her up and repair her when the economy is up and going. However, if she is not salvagable then we must put our efforts into getting sail training running on the Jeanie Johnston, she is practically ready to go and Im sure the Dublin Docklands would be happy to hand her over to Coiste.

January 31, 2009

A. G. Bailey III said:

The Raising Of The Asgard Just do it... She is surely of worth to Ireland's maritime history and culture...

January 31, 2009

Eleanor Morrissey said:

The raising of the Asgard The ship has served thousands of youth - irish and foreign over its life span. I had the luck to go on 3 trips. This ship is part of Irish maritime history. It has to be raised!

January 31, 2009

Suzanne Gebruers said:

The Raising of the Asgard She deserves better !

January 31, 2009

Igor Podgorski said:

Raise the Asgard She deserves better than to be left to rot, especially when there's no significant damage. Give her another life.

January 31, 2009

David Thomas-James said:

Mr. D. Thomas-James MA (Oxon) BSc (Hons) MIMech. E. AMPetE I hope all of us as professional people look forward to seeing a life for a lady.

January 31, 2009

Stefan Goor said:

Raise the Asgard The Asgard means so much anyone I've ever met that was ever involved with or sailed the ship and it's something for everyone from Ireland to be proud of. It would be wrong not to raise it, no replacement will ever have the same impact.

January 31, 2009

Emmanuel Le Clercq said:

... I am French, much interested in tall ships since 1988 and an early member of the French Association des Amis des Grands Voiliers - STA France. Asgard II is the 14th ship I sailed with. I have had this great pleasure three times between 2007 and 2008, and the honor to take part to the Watch Leader Training Course in March 2008, something I would not have expected being French. The last cruise was the Tall Ships Race of this summer, from Maloy to Den Helder. As a consequence, learning the very sad news just 3 weeks after disembarking has been a real shock. I just hope the ship can and will be raised, and will be ready to sail again with her when she will be repaired. Emmanuel Le Clercq Member AGV-STA France

January 31, 2009

Connel MccGuire said:

Plaese raise the Asgard Please raise her - it will prove the right decision in the end.

January 31, 2009

Ellen O'Callaghan said:

Raise the Asgard Please give future generations of young, and indeed older people, the opportunity to enjoy what my daughter enjoyed on her voyages aboard the Asgard.

January 31, 2009

tracy macken said:

raise the asgard please Considering all the hours people, crew and learners alike have put into this ship it's worth raising history

January 31, 2009

John Innes said:

Centre Principal www.aquatrek.ie Enough indecision - in the teeth of a recession it's time Ireland seized her billions in natural assets - the sea! FF governments have neglected our greatest resource noow for too long - Minister - Make a Decision!!!

January 31, 2009

misty said:

... raise her

January 31, 2009

David Egan said:

... Enough time has been wasted with her lying on the ocean floor now's the time to raise her! Don't have her destruction on your conscience Minister O'Dea!

February 01, 2009

Mairead Ni Chonghaile said:

Raise the Asgard II I urge the Irish Government not to use the current economic crisis as an excuse to abandon a ship and training programme which has brought much joy to decades of Irish students; raised the profile of Ireland abroad and acted as an ambassador fir our unique maritime heritage. It is now more than ever, that Ireland's youth require every skill that can be afforded them. The ship itself, whilst not remarkably old, is still a noteworthy vessel and over the years has become a powerful symbol of Ireland's heritage, which the Irish Government are duty-bound to protect. Is mise le meas...

February 01, 2009

Fiona Murphy said:

... Asgard II changed my life, she is a part of our countries history, it's a disgrace that she is still on the seabed. Please recognise the support, belief and honor that the Irish people have for Asgard II.

February 01, 2009

mike fahy said:

raise the asgard its more valuable to us as a functioning ship rather than sitting at the bottom of the ocean.....

February 01, 2009

Leo Delaney said:

Raise the Asgard II Sometimes the right thing to do costs money in the short term, but the benefits will be worth it in the long run.

February 01, 2009

Lorraine Moran said:

Raise her up Asgard has been an inspiration to me and so many others, it really is a shame to leave her their. Raise her up.

February 01, 2009

Vanessa Keane said:

Bring our sister home I sailed on the Asgard 11 back in 1993 and had a great experience and still hold fond memories of the Asgard 11. It's a terrible shame that the youth of today are currently missing out on the experiences of sailing on Asgard 11. Raise the Asgard 11 and bring her home.

February 01, 2009

Steph Sutton said:

... take everyone's vote into consideration, she ment so much to so many.

February 01, 2009

John Brennan said:

Board of DIrectors I read with irony that the Minister says he will make his decision in consulation with the Board of Coiste an Asgard. Traditionally, members of this board were involved with the sea and had an interest in the sea and sail training. However, look at the present board members now(Asgard website). Most of them are from Limerick(suprised?). We need to know the degree of their competence and knowledge of maritime matters. Why have they not done or said anything before now? The ship should have been lifted after the last survey in September. Given they are appointed by the government, I would suggest they are the voices of Minister O Dea and have no such intention. I hope I am proved wrong. Questions need to be asked.

February 01, 2009

emiliano curetti said:

... raise the Asgard

February 01, 2009

Raphaela O'Rorke said:

Save Asgard II She is such a beauty, it would be really sad to never set foot on her again. I have so many happy memories of both sailing and partying onboard and of all the amazing people i have met.

February 01, 2009

Paul Kearns said:

Captain Get her up Before it really is too late!

February 01, 2009

Conor Doyle said:

Please raise Asgard 2. I was fortunate enough to sail on the Asgard about 5 or 6 times and was truly heart broken to hear the news of her sinking. It was the experience and professionalism of her Captain and crew which ensured this tragedy was not far greter. I cannot put a value on the memories, friendships and skills that I obtained aboard Asgard2 which will stay with me for life. If Willie O'Dea and his government do not salvage the Asgard they are denying the young people of Ireland an oppurtunity to sail aboard one of the most beautiful tall ships in the world and learn the skills which will help them develop into valuable members of Irish society. I hope the right decision will be made, so that Coiste an Asgard can continue their invaluable work which is beneficial not only to the young people who sail aboard Asgard 2 but also Irish Society as a whole.

February 01, 2009

Warren said:

Raise The Asgard! ! ! Time grows short . . . Before it's too late, the ship needs to be rasied. Is this what O'Dea wants? She's in a salvagable condition, the money is available, what is the problem then? This ship should not be just a museum piece for future generations to look longfully upon, this should be the ship that the future generations train on!! have saiiled on this ship, I have trained on this ship, and it needs to be rased!!

February 01, 2009

Warren said:

. . . . . . . This petition is a testiment to the survival of this ship, and the country's feelings for her, so please raise her!

February 01, 2009

Chris Allman said:

Raise the Asgard Please raise the Asgard she is a beautiful vessel and her use working with the youth and people of Ireland will benefit Ireland in the future.

February 01, 2009

amaya said:

... it's a real shame to keep such a ship at the bottom of the sea. there are so many memories attached to it it would be super to make it a relic for all to see and to visit.

February 01, 2009

Helen O'Grady said:

... Hope she gets raised soon

February 01, 2009

Terence Kane said:

Asgard needs to rise like a salmon! Do the job minister

February 01, 2009

r.kendall said:

... a lovely craft, please raise if possible so that others may enjoy sailing on her.

February 01, 2009

Robbie Hynes said:

... Id love to see it raised! iv seen it before and i was on it in Sydney!

February 01, 2009

William Finnie said:

Mr. Raise the Asgard before it is too late. This boat is a national treasure.

February 01, 2009

Graham Harwood said:

Bring her up to dry out Raise the old girl so others can enjoy her...

February 01, 2009

David Chapple said:

Raising moral as well as Asgard II If there was any symbol that Ireland needed today for signs of hope and resurrection of our moral and spirits (and of course the economy), then the raising of the Asgard at this time and moment would be that ideal symbol. Act now!

February 01, 2009

Jenny O'Leary said:

Raise the Asgard please I sailed on Asgard 2 in 1994. Best 10 days of my life.... bar none! Have always promised myself I will sail on it again some day. Whenever I saw the boat in Cork Harbour it brought back such happy memories. It is possible to raise the boat so why not? So many more people deserve to have the wonderful experience I did.

February 01, 2009

Ted Law said:

Mr. A shame to see such inaction.

February 01, 2009

Niall Quinn said:

... Raise the Asgard.

February 01, 2009

Sarah Callaghan said:

... I hope this helps

February 01, 2009

Eileen Crowley said:

Raise the Asgard II As others have pointed out this action should have been taken months ago! Bring her home.

February 01, 2009

RONAN BEIRNE said:

... Save the Asgard 11 and give the nation something positive !

February 01, 2009

Ron Ferguson said:

It's the little things the voters remember. Asgard II, so symbolic in her green livery of a tiny Nation oft exposed in a World of hostility. She protected against the odds those who trusted in her timbers and sails; against gales and high seas. More so now than ever; Ireland needs Asgard II. Her vision meant so much to so many for so long . Her resurrection now would so represent loyalty; trust; decency; and above all hope.

February 01, 2009

Ray Kelly said:

... The Asgard is our national sail training ship and there is insurance for this dso why don't they use it!

February 01, 2009

David Reed said:

Reverend Father I wholeheartedly support this petetion, having seen Asgard 11 in Irish, Welsh and Cornish ports, observed the trainees enthusiastically working together in the interest of the ship, and having heard the the offspring of Irish friends recount their adventures. The ship and all she provides for the young people of Ireland is far too valuable to remain at the bottom of the sea, and so I urge those in authority to waste no time to raise her before she suffers further, refit her and get her doing the job she does so well - helping the young folk of Ireland to grow into mature responsible citizens, and get fun at he same time.

February 01, 2009

John Mack said:

2nd time Signing this.. Re-signing this because every day when I re-read through the names of people who signed it, I see another name that I know well and hold dear. I don't know every name name here but I do recognise names from sailing clubs, Officers of the the Irish Merchant Navy, Irish Naval Service personal, RNLI, Asgard Support Group, full time Asgard crew and fishermen, these are the people who hold sailing close to their hearts every day.. these are the people who get a lump in their throats when they hear about bad weather at sea, or a craft in diffuiclty we are a close knit group where social background is not taken in to account. Minister as an other signee pointed out the Jeanie Johnston can be used as a short term measure. We are an Island nation with the oldest sailing club in the world and we the people are begging our government to reinstate a sail training program.. please listen to us.. read the names and put faces to them.. You will be surprised to know that we come from all backgrounds and are spread out thought the world we are the ambassadors of Ireland, tour guides, in each and every way to this Island Nation... Your Nation.

February 01, 2009

Pierce Purcell said:

MR raise the asgard!

February 01, 2009

Eva O' Brien said:

Asgard! My time on the Asgard was epic.. One of the best experiences of my life!

February 02, 2009

Theo Dorgan said:

Poet, writer One year after the Civil War ended, Conor O'Brien carried the tricolour of the new state around the world on his 2-year circumnavigation. Our tricolour flew on the first yacht to round Cape Horn, and since then it has flown on the seven seas, speaking of us as an island people, a people of the sea. It is no accident that as our economy founders on the rocks of greed and mismanagement, the sea has taken Asgard — a sign, if we know how to read it, that we have been following a delusional course. If we need a metaphor for what we need now as a people, then let the salvage of Asgard be that metaphor; let us restore her to her glory, and let her carry the flag once more to the four corners of the world.

February 02, 2009

Aoife Murphy said:

... please raise it to keep all those asguard mad people happy

February 02, 2009

peter foley said:

Dr Yes raise the Asgard in light of it's significant role in Ireland's recent past.

February 02, 2009

Patrick Kennedy said:

... The Asgard has become part of Ireland's sea-going heritage and should be preserved for future generations. Please do the right thing and raise her as quickly as possible.

February 02, 2009

eric coates said:

Mr Waste no time start proceedings of salvage immediately before the ship is damaged more and then you will regret it !!!! Thanks

February 02, 2009

Jocelyn Newman said:

... I remember seeing the Asgard in Sydney harbour 1988 Tall Ships Race. What a great ambassador for Ireland she was. Please waste no time in raising this beautiful ship.

February 02, 2009

Fiona Breen said:

... Please, please please raise this beautiful ship!! She does not deserve to be left at the bottom of the sea. Asgard II is very special and important to so many people. She is a huge part of our history and has touched the lives of so many. Some of the best memories of my life were on board this beautiful ship! Everything possible should be done to save her!! Please!!

February 02, 2009

Brendan Bleheen said:

... Stop wasting time!

February 02, 2009

Emmet Dalton said:

Mr Raise the Asgard!

February 02, 2009

Mary Campbell said:

... Bring her Home !!

February 02, 2009

Rachel O'Toole said:

... Raise the Asgard!

February 02, 2009

Davwe McGloughlin said:

Deputy Managing Director In these times it's important to know what really matters. Our young people need formative experiences before material wealth. For this and a million other reasons you need to do the right thing. Raise the Asgard and bring some joy to the country.

February 02, 2009

Rebecca Deasy said:

... Raise the Asgard!!!

February 02, 2009

Catherine Duggan said:

... xxxxxxxxx

February 02, 2009

Andrew Carey - Team Delta Lloyd PRO Ireland & UK said:

Raise it As many people have noted, Ireland has a few iconic symbols and the history that this country has in sailing is second to none. The Asgard is one of those very symbols and it is known worldwide. Sitting on the bottom of the sea is no place for such a ship steeped in history and despite any economic difficulties that the country and the world may be experiencing, both time and money should be afforded to maintaining our history and raising this tall ship that has given so much to the world of sailing.

February 02, 2009

Celine Blacow said:

... Raise the Asgard - my niece has sailed with her many times.

February 02, 2009

George Tottenham said:

Asgard 2 The longer she sits down there the more she shall cost to put right. GT

February 02, 2009

Maeve Lucey said:

... Bring Asgard home

February 02, 2009

Jim Corr said:

sailor Been on tall ships for 0ver 25 years both in the States and Ireland. I have never seen any maritime nation neglect its history, artifacts, and memories as we do here. We are a small nation that has sent our people all over the world for hundreds of years. Most of them left in small ships. A lot of them worked on small ships. I know times are tough but that is when we find out what is important. " Like the Mary Ellen Carter, let her rise again" We need inspiration in these times, don't become like the bean counters of the world. She helped a lot of kids get their feet on the ground and a start in life. Now it's time for to give her something back. Bring her home!

February 02, 2009

Matt Treadwell said:

Shame on this incompetent government This government has proved itself quite capable of wasting money on minister's hairdos whilst on junkets, electronic voting etc, etc, etc, but will not commit to raising a ship which did immeasurable good for Ireland since commissioned. Shame on them! I hope it's not too late for this fine vessel, I have never sailed on her but know quite a few who did from both sailing and non-sailing backgrounds and all say how great an experience it was. Minister, it's time to make a positive decision to invest in this country's maritime future! Raise the Asgard 11 for restoration.

February 02, 2009

Niamh Sweeney said:

Ms As a former Asgard II trainee, I know the wonderful experiences she has provided over the years and I think it is important that those experiences can be enjoyed by the next generations. Please try to salvage the Asgard.

February 02, 2009

Mike Medcalf said:

... please raise the Asgard

February 02, 2009

Aoife Fannin said:

... Raise the Asgard!!!

February 02, 2009

ger foley said:

... sailing training teaches more than sailing. all young people benefit whether or not they ever set foot on a boat again.

February 02, 2009

Sean Cullen said:

Hydrographer - INFOMAR Surely its cheaper to raise the Asgard II than build a new one - which we will need?

February 02, 2009

Maeve Gebruers said:

... Please, please raise Asgard II! Sailed on her back in the early 90s, what an experience. It should be around for my kids to have similar experiences in the future.

February 02, 2009

John Walsh said:

Raise the Asgard and raise our spirits and profile As a recent trainee (in my 60s) I was struck by the instant cameraderies between the youger and older trainees - a mutually beneficial experience

February 02, 2009

Brian Crawford said:

... Get on with it and stop the delay

February 02, 2009

John O'Reilly said:

Mr. Please save Asgard II. I learnt my early sailing on board Asgard I and the Creidne - each of these vessels and Asgard II have been fantastic Ambassadors for Ireland, everywhere we went everyone wanted to visit the Irish ship. It is a wonderful sail training experience for our young sailors. If she can't be salvaged we must commission a new Irish Sail Training vessel.

February 02, 2009

Conor O'Leary said:

Mr Minister, it is sometimes difficult to take the long view of events especially in times of national crisis. And it can be especially difficult to see the significance of an icon such as the Asgard II and what it will mean for generations of Irish people to come. In Denmark and Sweden they look after their maritime history with great pride and at great expense. This is not surprising - these ships are part of a people's history and their culture , they define us in some way. You have to imagine someone in 100 or 200 years time looking at the Asgards I and II sitting proudly in a gleaming new museum in the heart of Dublin city and understanding how these ships are a narrative of the birth and development of our nation. Unless you believe history is over of course and not your responisbility. Have we as a nation evolved in 90 years to adulthood or do we continue to behave with the short sightedness of teenagers? Remember Todd Andrews is still thought of as short sighted - not because he closed the Harcourt Street line (that was the zietgeist of the 50s and 60s in Britain and Ireland) - rather he failed to have the vision to imagine a day when they could re open the line and never took steps to keep the integrity of the permanent way. Raise the Asgard II now, stop the clock and we can restore her at leisure.

February 02, 2009

Colm Penston said:

... Please raise this beautiful brig, I served my apprenticeship on the construction of Asgard II, and myself and the rest of the workers from Jack Tyrrell's in Arklow were the first to sail her, I'll never forget the experience.Please raise her before the Bay of Biscay and the trawlers claim her.

February 02, 2009

Naomi Guerin said:

... Asgard - Experience of a lifetime!

February 02, 2009

Richard Mills said:

Asgard II This is a valuable and historic vessel and action needs to be taken now, without delay, to raise it. Future generations will find procrastination inexcusable.

February 02, 2009

Barry Shaughnessy said:

... Get her up

February 02, 2009

Stephen Harris said:

Generations Both my parents sailed Asgard. I met my wife on Asgard. Are my children to be denied this experience by the government's inactivity?

February 02, 2009

Adrian van der Lee said:

Raise our Spirits! Will we ever see her like again? Raise our ship - raise our flag - raise our spirits.

February 02, 2009

Roger Kirker said:

... Asgard ll is a wonderful example of Irish craftsmanship, and has been , and could continue to be a tremendous ambassador for Ireland and her maritime heritage. So, Minister, why sit on the fence, bite the bullet and use the insurance for the cause it was paid for, and raise the vessel.

February 02, 2009

Vanessa Mack said:

... rescue her before it's too late

February 02, 2009

Colm Doherty said:

Save the Asgard It's part of Ireland's cultural capital & heritage - far too valuable not to rescue it. Recessions come & go, but that would be a betrayal of future generations.

February 02, 2009

Michael Mc Donnell said:

Owner/operator the Viking Ship, Athlone Please raise this beautiful ship as I have been on it several times and can vouch for the social and educational aspect that it provides especially to young people and gives them a sense of respondsibility and a knowledge of what leadership is all about!

February 02, 2009

David Bolger said:

Raise the Asgard Raise the Asgard

February 02, 2009

Caoimhe Murphy said:

... This is important; the money would be well spent. I believe here would be good will out there for this project, despite the recession.

February 02, 2009

Stephen Mullaney said:

... raise it. raise it.

February 02, 2009

Adrian Power said:

... go on, go on, go on!

February 02, 2009

byrne said:

Asgard how to move forward good morning all " she was 90 feet tall 20 feet wide and she drew about 9 foot 6 she had a crew that were lazy driven half crazy looking for a sturgeon fix, we didn't sail very fast, but had a lot of laughs on the stv Asgard...." i am a product of asgard and her world, for over 25 years now i have earned a living from boats of one type or another. maintenance on asgard, resorting local boats, boat man for "whbc", skipper of a class 4 & 5 passenger boat classic sailing races etcetc, in short i think i am qualified to give an imput here. Asgard 2 is dead she will not be economically raised she will not be economically rebuilt infact after the winter storms on Biscay (where i have sailed a lot) i would say there is nothing left to lift apart from the hope and dreams of her fan's. so lets look at where we are: we have the organisation we have the collective interest we (the gov) have the insurance money. 3.5 million euro i believe. firstly lets hire a vessel, of which there are MANY AVAILABLE for this season. secondly for less than 1 million we could build 4 new Kinsale Hookers. a real traditional irish boat about 45 feet deep keel. this design exists on paper only as we have already lost her whole class. (the nearest is Faimera a 45ft galway hooker) i can name 4 yards in the uk that would build these at the large budget of 250,000 each. these are professional wooden ship builders. for the balance of the 2.5 million, less the cost of chartering the "ts" ship for this year, we can train sailors to crew professionally the hookers, we can extend our training ship experience to a wider audience, and i can honestly say we would still have money left over!!!! in short we could give every transition year student at least 1 week on a sail training vessel. we are a maritime nation lets not turn our backs on the youth of Ireland bu letting political people wast the legacy that Asgard has given us. mick byrne ferry king mkpbyrne@eircom.net 00 353 (0 ) 87 7776199

February 02, 2009

Dan Bolger said:

Mr. Raise her or spend the €3.8m insurance on the Asgard III.

February 02, 2009

Pat Keane said:

Bring up the Asgard The insurance company has indicated that they will pay for it, so what could possibly have prevented the boat from being raised? The lack of a credible reason is curious, if not ominous. A little bit more transparency would help alleviate worries. Please don't just pocket the money and run.

February 02, 2009

Kieran Crowley said:

... Raising the Asgard is a symbol of resilience and pride in Irsh craftsmanship in these gloomy times.

February 02, 2009

Jack Crowley said:

... come on Willie. it be be your personal monument

February 02, 2009

Bob Hobby said:

Raise the Asgard, Minister ...yes, you can!

February 02, 2009

Joshua Waterstone said:

Raise the Asgard Allow the privilege to the next generation

February 02, 2009

Aisling Phelan said:

Raise Her And continue the Asgard experience - a lifetime of memories

February 02, 2009

DMcK said:

Raise the Asgard Asgard has a job to do, No videos, games or books can do what Asgard does.

February 02, 2009

Ciaran Hynes said:

... should be raised immediately before she's totally destroyed.

February 02, 2009

Evanna Lyons said:

Raise the Asgard As important as Newgrange or Tara as a national monument, its part of our history and has represented Ireland on so many occasions. This legacy cannot be lost!

February 02, 2009

Gareth Nihill said:

Bring her home Asgard has to be salvaged. She is a national treasure. This ship has a value that can't be quantified by an insurance policy. The people who have sailed her have an emotional attachment that can't be explained in words. The country needs it's hardest working ambassador returned to it's former glory and put to sea once more.

February 02, 2009

Cormac Clancy said:

B.L. If the report says she can be raised - do it ! If she can't, then qo qet Asgard III immediately - no delays, just a "Yes we can" attitude from the entire cabinet - the good that Asgard has done cannot be measured in money alone, but if it were the cost benefit analysis would surely show a vast profit to the exchequer - nothing but good comes from voluntary enterprise and involvement of this nature.

February 02, 2009

Russell Orpen said:

... Jack Tyrrell must be swearing in his grave, his pride and joy lying on the sea bed. As far as I know it's not in very deep water so surely it's not beyond the abilities of salvors to tackle using inflatable chambers or something like that. Would like to think that would be the case anyway.

February 02, 2009

Holly Clarke said:

... Please raise the Asgard

February 02, 2009

Paul Whooley said:

Get her up! Come on lads!

February 02, 2009

Robin Strahan said:

Raise the Asgard Raise the Asgard

February 02, 2009

Timothy O'Reilly said:

... Please raise the Asgard.

February 02, 2009

Eberhard Bort said:

Mr It'd be a shame if the Asgard II would have to rot at the bottom of the sea!

February 02, 2009

Deirdre Nic Unfraidh said:

Ms Ardaigh an Asgard

February 02, 2009

Derek Conway said:

Drag it up!!! Drag it up

February 02, 2009

Walter Sammon said:

Mr Its all been written already, time for action.

February 02, 2009

Mary H said:

... It will be sad day for Ireland if the Asgard is left on the seabed. Only a sadman could make such a decision. Raise her up now

February 02, 2009

Sam Clarke said:

Asgard II Please raise the Asgard before its too late

February 02, 2009

Aisling Ahern said:

Raise the Asgard I've been on board the asgard four times, it's one of those experiences you really learn an awful bout so much from. I'd hate others to be deprived of this experience.

February 02, 2009

Sarah bates said:

... the asgard should be risen, i have such good memories of sailing on her, it would be a shame to deny others the chance of such an experience.

February 02, 2009

Laura said:

Raise it! Bring it back up!

February 02, 2009

Mary Maher said:

Petition I sailed on Asgard three times before going on to do a transatlantic crossing on a British tall ship. My experience on Asgard gave me the confidence to go on to do the longer voyage and I have memories that I will treasure forever.

February 02, 2009

byrne said:

... good morning all " she was 90 feet tall 20 feet wide and she drew about 9 foot 6 she had a crew that were lazy driven half crazy looking for a sturgeon fix, we didn't sail very fast, but had a lot of laughs on the stv Asgard...." i am a product of asgard and her world, for over 25 years now i have earned a living from boats of one type or another. maintenance on asgard, resorting local boats, boat man for "whbc", skipper of a class 4 & 5 passenger boat classic sailing races etcetc, in short i think i am qualified to give an imput here. Asgard 2 is dead she will not be economically raised she will not be economically rebuilt infact after the winter storms on Biscay (where i have sailed a lot) i would say there is nothing left to lift apart from the hope and dreams of her fan's. so lets look at where we are: we have the organisation we have the collective interest we (the gov) have the insurance money. 3.5 million euro i believe. firstly lets hire a vessel, of which there are MANY AVAILABLE for this season. secondly for less than 1 million we could build 4 new Kinsale Hookers. a real traditional irish boat about 45 feet deep keel. this design exists on paper only as we have already lost her whole class. (the nearest is Faimera a 45ft galway hooker) i can name 4 yards in the uk that would build these at the large budget of 250,000 each. these are professional wooden ship builders. for the balance of the 2.5 million, less the cost of chartering the "ts" ship for this year, we can train sailors to crew professionally the hookers, we can extend our training ship experience to a wider audience, and i can honestly say we would still have money left over!!!! in short we could give every transition year student at least 1 week on a sail training vessel. we are a maritime nation lets not turn our backs on the youth of Ireland bu letting political people wast the legacy that Asgard has given us. mick byrne

February 02, 2009

Niall Heffernan said:

... Please raise the ship, a wonderfull speciman, enjoyed by thousands, and hopefully thousands more

February 02, 2009

Mark Healy said:

Raise the Asgard It's the right thing to do. Resume the sail training programme asap.

February 02, 2009

grainne arntz said:

Raise the Asgard Asgard must be raised and sail again!

February 02, 2009

Stephan said:

Bring her back home!!! It is a real shame that nothing as been done since the Asgard II sank!!! It certainly doesn't give a good picture of Ireland in respect to its heritage...like many things I am afraid, we are loosing our values and respect!! By now the Asgard II must be in a sorry state lying in only 83 m of water!! A survey should be done, and yes, if the Asgard II can be salvaged, well, don't waste your time and bring her back home!!!

February 02, 2009

Ann said:

... I hope this Minister will do the right thing and Raise Asgard and bring her Home, to give the people of Ireland the pleasure of seeing her set sail again.

February 02, 2009

Brian Lynch said:

... Raise the vessel before she becomes a total loss.

February 02, 2009

Seamus & Edda O'Colmain said:

... Really it's long past time that she was raised. Do it now!

February 02, 2009

Kilian D'Arcy said:

Raise A Part Of History Raise A Part Of History That Has Touched Peoples Hearts And That Has Made An Impact In Peoples Lives That Have Sailed On Asgard II. People Have Said To Me That They Do Not Think Its Going To Happen Well I Think It Should Happen. I Go From A Saying From Barack Obama. Can We Raise The Asgard II ?. The Answer Is: Yes We Can.

February 02, 2009

Rachel Crowley said:

... Even if she's being ripped up at the bottom of the sea, she's depreciating less than a lot of other shares in this country. Find out if it's genuinely possible (without wasting a lot of money) to raise Asgard, then do it. It would be refreshing for a quick decision to be made by this government, that was quickly implemented, for the good of all the young people on this island. Consider it an investment.

February 02, 2009

Kevin Lynch said:

Mr. I think it is outragous that the Minister of Defence (Mr O'Dea) has not initiated the raising of the Asgard II before now. Any more time lost is a deriliction of responsability to the Irish Nation....an island Nation

February 02, 2009

Anne Murphy said:

... If the Asgard is not raised now, in about 20 years the government of the time will think that it is a good idea to raise it up for the sake of Irish history, and because once upon a time we were an island nation with a national sail training vessel, and we cared about our children and our nation. when it is raised it will be beyond repair and then they will build a new Asgard. Why not be brave now Mr. O'Dea show us what you are made of, make the island nation proud and raise the Asgard, we should not be the only country without a sail training vessel. Grasp this opportunity make the hard decision, it will be worth it, think of the glory when it is restored to its former glory and you can launch it again - just do it. For the sake of the Asgard loving Irish doit, doit, doit, doit, doit, doit, doit. We need the Asgard.................

February 02, 2009

Sarah Arntz said:

Raise the Asgard now! Raise the Asgard! It was incredibly hard to see her go down that night in September and we really need her back! She is part of our heritage and more people should be able to experience sailing on her!

February 02, 2009

Bill Kavanagh said:

Captain Asgard 2 is a great Ambassador for Ireland and the best sail training vessel in Europe. She is versatile, manoeuvrable and forgiving. Perfect for sail training.

February 02, 2009

Mark Dineen said:

... While the government dithers we lose a great national treasure. Please raise the Asgard.

February 02, 2009

Nicki Wood said:

Raise the Asgard Please raise the Asgard!

February 02, 2009

Sarah Murphy said:

... The experience of sailing and living on such a wonderful ship should be available to all in this country. From 1988 untill 1997 I did over ten voyages on board that beautiful vessel and it has shaped the person I am. I cannot believe that we can allow her to be left at the bottom of the ocean. Infact, I still can't believe that she sank. I still expect to see her gliding silently into Baltimore or Dublin Bay. Bring her home!

February 02, 2009

james lynsh said:

... come on, just sign it all ready!!!!!!!

February 02, 2009

DONAL LYNCH said:

... There is more than enough insurance money there to raise Asgard II and there is an approved salvage contractor. Why is nothing being done? Asgard II should have been raised within weeks. It is now almost 6 months since she sank. Does Willie O'Dea want his name to be remembered for saving Asgard II or for abandoning her?

February 02, 2009

Terry said:

Mr Raise the Asgard!!!...do it,...do it!

February 02, 2009

John Inge Bacher said:

... Greatings from Norway and te Norwegian Gaffrigg Sailors out of Horten town, and old traditional Naval town. Boys'n Girls! Get her afloat just do it. Asgard has to get afloat, so just do it !!

February 02, 2009

JAMES MULROONEY said:

... The Asgard, a national treasure.

February 02, 2009

Gemma said:

what are you waiting for? The survey last week has shown her to be in the same location and with her rig largely intact. We have been told that there will be £3.8 million insurance money and that the salvage operation will cost approx half of it which leaves half of it for restoration....it makes sense!! We have seen how much the building of new tallships have cost in the past with the Jeanie and the Dunbrody. Both magnificent vessels but neither suitable for sail training. We have a unique, purpose built vessel sitting on the sea floor just waiting to be rescued. Having sailed on board on numerous occasions including the opening of the Newry canal and Tallships 2000 in New York and Boston I have seen how Asgard is an ambassador for our country, small and green but full of highs spirits and positivity. Let’s see some of this positivity and raise the spirits of the Irish people...both those of us who have been privileged to have sailed on board and those who haven't. Asgard has been a major part of my and I hope she continues to be. Waiting for the right decision to made..you know what it is, Gemma PS Minister, I recommend that once you raise her Minister and she is back on the high seas that you book yourself on board and see what everyone has been talking about it...you certainly won't regret!

February 02, 2009

Con Meegan said:

Raise her......... She can and should be raised,between the insurance and some lotto funds this is more than feasable..........lets do it!

February 02, 2009

Jonathan Wigham said:

... I have sailed on the Asgard several times and looked forward to sailing on her again. Every day she is at the bottom of the sea is damaging her further. Lift her now and let her thrill future generations of young Irish people.

February 02, 2009

Charlie Cullen said:

Do the right thing! Yet another example of the inability of this government to actually make a decision or do the right thing. Shame on the government and shame on you Minister O'Dea! As an island nation steeped in a rich maritime history, the neglect of all things maritime, by officialdom in this country, over the years has been both astonishing and shameful. Will anyone forget the immense pride felt by all Irish people in July 2005 when hundreds of thousands of people from Ireland and indeed all over the world visited Waterford to attend the prestigeous International Tall Ships event. The organisers in Waterford did Ireland proud and immense pride was the overiding feeling that weekend as the 3 fabulous Irish Tall Ships (Asgard II, Jeanie Johnston & Dunbrody) sailed together out of Waterford. The benefits and rewards of sail training extend far beyond the actual voyage itself. This country needs to continue with the sail training programme. Quit the dithering and give the go-ahead to raise this fine ship without further delay, while there is still something left to salvage and get her back into commission as soon as possible. In the meantime, the Jeanie Johnston is an obvious temporary replacement as the national sail trainig vessel.

February 02, 2009

Janine Dixon said:

Just do it! A ship who has enriched so many lives doesn't deserve to be forgotten

February 02, 2009

Jane Murphy said:

... Insurance money is there, kindly use it!

February 02, 2009

Susan Hanley-Place MBE said:

Master of the 110ft Brigantine ZEBU, out of Liverpool ASGARD must be raised. Awaiting better weather is necessary as it will not be an easy salvage, but the Insurers are "on board". If Willie O'Dea hesitates about the end cost - just go for it, Minister -take the first neccessary step. Merseyside volunteers were the key to ZEBUs resurrection; Irish people will be there for ASGARD. Contact us -we have travelled this road and how we did it will be helpful. Hopefully, the Irish Sea's Brigantines will one day Race together.

February 02, 2009

ian james power said:

mr a must have for a island nation and for people of all ages

February 02, 2009

Deirdre Duffy said:

... Raise her up I say, she deserves it, some of the best days of my life were on that ship, everybody should have access to such an amazing, innovative resource. Long live Asgard II!

February 02, 2009

Achim Liebold said:

AL ...some things are worth saving for the next generation!!

February 03, 2009

Sophie G said:

Why not? In this day and age when we are focusing on getting young people outdoors and being active, if the insurance money's there there's no valid reason not to raise her. Learning to sail has enriched so many people's lives. What a waste it would be to leave her to rot!

February 03, 2009

Sarah Morrissey said:

Please raise her Please raise her so my two childern can have the same adventures on her that i did.

February 03, 2009

Damien Kelleher said:

My Love of the Sea began on the Asgard 2 I only learned of this petition by word on mouth. But, i hope the word spreads like wildfire that the Asgard 2 needs to be raised! I was lucky enough to have competed 3 adventures on this wonderful vessel and after that i was bitten by the bug. SInce then i have spent most of my adult years on the bridges of various merchant vessels and when i think of the Asgard 2, i have nothing but fond memories! This vessel is a part of irelands soul like the cliffs of moher or the GPO........She must be raised and repaired. Do the right thing! Bring her home to Ireland!

February 03, 2009

Jessica Bates said:

... Sailing on the Asgard II is such an unforgettable experience, more people should get the chance to do so.

February 03, 2009

Aisling McCarthy said:

... Raise the Asgard!

February 03, 2009

Malcolm Blacow said:

... It seems close to ridiculous that in such miserable times we are denied any good news. An iconic symbol of Ireland's nautical heritage lays at the bottom of the sea, much like our flagging spirits. So why not give us cause to celebrate and refloat this wonderful ship? Damn the recession, lets have something to be proud of!

February 03, 2009

Noeleen Hurley said:

What are you waiting for - 145 days now since Asgard II went down The finance (insurance)is there to lift the ship. I do not think there is one person in the whole country who would not agree that this is the right and only choice to be made. After all who amongst us has not either sailed on her, some many times, or has a relation or friend who has. So Minister O'Dea, please sign those papers now...restore Asgard II to Ireland, before it is too late...give us something positive to think about our current government...and give the future young people of the country the chance to sail on her...

February 03, 2009

Ruth-Ann Shields said:

... I had the best 10 days sailing from Dingle to Cork in 2004. Its such a pity to leave her below. A wonderful ship that gave me wonderful memories.

February 03, 2009

Billy Payne said:

Old sailor for thirty years. Let her sail the Seven Seas again. And build better and stronger people for Ireland.

February 03, 2009

vivian Nathan said:

... Best Wishes for a reincarntion of the Asguard

February 03, 2009

Liam McMullin said:

Dr. Whatever about its usefulness while afloat, to leave it where it is suggests we don't care/can't do it. Not good PR! Liam McMullin

February 03, 2009

Don McBrien said:

... get on with it

February 03, 2009

Orlaith Brennan said:

... This is the ideal opportunity to bring some much needed cheer and something positive to the people of Ireland. Is this going to be another example of the misappropriation of Irish money, why bother paying insurance if you then decide to leave her sitting at the bottom of the sea!?! Are we seeing yet more short sightedness by the government? What is wrong with our elected representatives that they can't see the wonderful opportunity that they are going to leave to rot. Not only is she a fantastic boat but her restoration and subsequent return to service will provide much needed employment. The Tall Ships Race in 2011 is due to start in Waterford and then continue around the south, west and north coasts of Ireland. Are we to welcome tall ships from around the world and enjoy the revenue generated from this event knowing that we left our beloved entry to this race 80m below water in the Bay of Biscay. Minister, do the right thing for all concerned, yourself included, and raise the Asgard II.

February 03, 2009

Peter Harris said:

... Over the years Asgard turning many a troubled youth into a stable member of society. Economically her running costs are surely justified by the associated reduction in crime, drug use and broken families. The cost of salvage & refitting seems to be covered by insurance. The refitting work will create jobs. I really don't see a down side to raising such a magnificent symbol of national pride. Peter

February 03, 2009

Steve Canavan said:

... In a time when economic sense has to enter any government decision, raising Asgard makes sense. The insurance money will pay for the lift and refitting and in a time when our youth face a very uncertain future the confidence and competance that an experiance on Asgard brings is surely a priceless comodity in the near future.The ship has to be raised,the expense to the state will be too great otherwise and the thought of no sail training vessel is an utterly unthinkable outcome.

February 03, 2009

Simon O'Keeffe said:

... Generally, it's only when we have lost something that its true value becomes obvious. This is a rare chance for society to recover something lost. Grasp the opportunty for all of us, Minister!

February 03, 2009

Corinne Hitching said:

Asgard II Please please consider raising Asgard and not trying to build another. She was so amazingly loved by everyone in sail training and the sailing world and could never be replaced. It must be cheaper in the long run to raise her than re-build her and the publicity you will get from raising her and getting her back on the water would be massive!

February 03, 2009

Paddy Boxall said:

... I did a delivery trip from Melbourne to Sydney in 1988 as a member of the "wrinkly" crew and made life long friends during her time in Sydney. When one British tabloid reported the Australian Bicentenial Parade of sail in 1988, it was stated that even if the Irish Sail Training Vessel was one of the smallest ships in the fleet she had the biggest heart. For once they got it right! Surely it would be cheaper to raise her than build another. She is loved not only in Ireland but around the world.

February 03, 2009

Joyce van den Hoven said:

Please raise Asgard II Dear Sir or Madam, As a volunteer on various Tall Ships over the past 8 years - I have seen first hand the change one trip can make. I only had the fortune to sail on Asgard II once, but the ship and her crew left a massive impression on me - such comeradery, the right balance between learning and having fun - there is no way that you can replace that. I was shocked and dumbfounded when I found out what had happened to her, and I can only hope that you do everything possible to raise her from the sea bed and restore her to her former glory. Yours sincerely, Joyce van den Hoven

February 03, 2009

Eileen Carpio said:

Raise the Asgard Many of my friends have travelled on the Asgard and their journeys have been exciting, challenging, vibrant, educational and without fail ever-lasting. It seems a shame that we cannot save this precious vessel that has given so much to so many. To old and young, to the experienced and to amateurs. SO, RAISE THE ASGARD!!!!

February 03, 2009

Grainne said:

Please raise Asgard II I did a trip on Asgard II during the Tall Ships in 2001 - an amazing experience. The ship was insured, the insurance funds should be used to raise her immediately - what are they waiting for??? I hope other people, young and old get to have the Asgard II experience in the years to come. Raise the Asgard II now.

February 03, 2009

Brendan Murphy said:

... Raise the Asgard!

February 03, 2009

Michael Hennigan said:

Raise the Asgard She's a national treasure!

February 03, 2009

Vince Goggin said:

Rise her up How about a good news story on the Six-One News for a change, insurance funds are available so JUST DO IT!

February 03, 2009

PAUL MURPHY said:

... Thr ship must be raised.

February 03, 2009

Mike Millis said:

Volunteer - Sail Training International Asgard has participated for many years in the Tall Ship Races and has represented the best of Irish youth. It has been the face of Ireland and deserves to be raised and renovated for the sake of youth training and developement.

February 03, 2009

Brian Turvey said:

Issue of Heritage Minister, This is an issue that we will not be thanked for by the generations that would only be left with photos, old video and stories of travel, heroism and coming of age. You know it is the right thing to do.....raise the Asgard II.

February 03, 2009

Ingunn Silberg said:

... I agree she deserves better. She brought all of us something unique, and she brought out the best in us. For some of us she, changed our lives forever.

February 03, 2009

Nina Gracey said:

Asgard It would be a shame if the next generation missed out!!

February 03, 2009

Geraldine O'Brien said:

... I was one of the trainees on the Asgard when she went down on September 11th. The captain and crew were just brilliant. It would be criminal if the Asgard was left on the seabed. She should be raised and put back on the water so thousands of others can avail of the opportunity of sailing on her again

February 03, 2009